Need help with my writing homework on Is Multiculturalism Bad for Women. Write a 2000 word paper answering; Okin begins by developing an argument that the rights of some groups can be endangering to women. She considers the example of the French administration affording numerous male immigrants special permissions to bring more than one wife into the nation regardless of the fact that the laws of the country do not allow polygamy and the wives are bitterly opposed to this practice1. According to Okin, if there is the agreement that women should not be underprivileged based on their sex, the group rights that allow oppressive practices on the basis that they are essential to the minority whose existence could be threatened, should not be allowed2.
Some opponents do not agree with the position held by Okin on this issue and contend that the views she holds are entrenched in an ethical diversity that has no consideration for cultural dissimilarities. Critics dispute with her focus on gender while others come up with the argument that care should be taken regarding the group rights that can be allowed, but not rejecting the category of group rights in totality. Okin makes her conclusion with a contradiction, clarification, adjustment and extension of her initial position.
Even if a particular practice associated with a specific culture may be perceived as repressive to the people that are not part of that culture or feminists, it is seldom justified to interfere, except for the circumstances where the person may not be able to practice any form of agency, especially small children. Regarding all other cases, any answers to what might be considered as a problem must originate from the people themselves and not from quarters that are not within the culture. People should be able to practice their agency in the cultures that are every so often considered as repressive and each case should be assessed based on its context.