Cross-cultural research can make significant and indeed truly extraordinary contributions to positive social change. Studies in multiple nations can examine issues of race, class, and gender and provide data and evidence that may be utilized to inform social policies and projects to move society towards more equity and fewer health disparities. Additionally, cross-cultural research can help inform discussions about best treatment and intervention practices, and how these treatments and practices are best adapted and modified to be most effective to diverse groups.
Examine social issues related to cross-cultural research and positive social change.
Psychological research is more than an intellectual exercise. Data and evidence from cross-cultural work can be utilized to implement positive social change. For example, psychologists have worked on such social issues as global poverty, health disparities, and equality among groups. Other examples for positive social change one can consider how such research can be utilized to improve treatments and interventions for psychological disorders or for educational programs. For example, if research was only conducted in one culture, psychologists would not know whether the educational or therapy intervention that worked well in one culture works well or even works at all in another culture. Thus, conducting cross-cultural research can really lead to improved outcomes in many domains of relevance, such as in schools and in the counseling center.
Examine a social issue and explore ways that cross-cultural research can impact positive social change.
Post and briefly describe the social issue you selected and explain at least three ways that cross-cultural psychology research can inform policy change to improve society.
Note: Be sure to support your postings and responses with specific references to the Learning Resources and identify current relevant literature to support your work.
nity-based approach to assisting war-affected children. In
U. P. Gielen, J. Fish, & J. G. Draguns (Eds.), Handbook of
culture, therapy, and healing (pp. 321–341). Mahwah, NJ:
Erlbaum.
Wessells, M., & Monteiro, C. (2006). Psychosocial assis-
tance for youth: Toward reconstruction for peace in An-
gola. Journal of Social Issues, 62(1), 121–139.
Wessells, M., & Winter, D. (Eds.). (1998). The Graca
Machel/UN Study on the effects of war on children
[Special issue]. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace
Psychology, 4.
Do No Harm: Toward Contextually
Appropriate Psychosocial Support in
International Emergencies
Michael G. Wessells
Columbia University and Randolph-Macon College
In the aftermath of international emergencies caused by
natural disasters or armed conflicts, strong needs exist for
psychosocial support on a large scale. Psychologists have
developed and applied frameworks and tools that have
helped to alleviate suffering and promote well-being in
emergency settings. Unfortunately, psychological tools and
approaches are sometimes used in ways that cause
unintended harm. In a spirit of prevention and wanting to
support critical self-reflection, the author outlines key
issues and widespread violations of the do no harm
imperative in emergency contexts. Prominent issues include
contextual insensitivity to issues such as security,
humanitarian coordination, and the inappropriate use of
various methods; the use of an individualistic orientation
that does not fit the context and culture; an excessive focus
on deficits and victimhood that can undermine
empowerment and resilience; the use of unsustainable,
short-term approaches that breed dependency, create
poorly trained psychosocial workers, and lack appropriate
emphasis on prevention; and the imposition of outsider
approaches. These and related problems can be avoided by
the use of critical self-reflection, greater specificity in
ethical guidance, a stronger evidence base for intervention,
and improved methods of preparing international
humanitarian psychologists.
Keywords: psychosocial support, emergencies, unintended
harm, resilience, cultural insensitivity
Large-scale emergencies such as tsunamis and armed con-
flicts create not only massive physical destruction but also
an enormous toll of psychological and social suffering
(Boothby, Strang, & Wessells, 2006; Cardozo, Talley, Bur-
ton, & Crawford, 2004; de Jong, 2002; Marsella, Borne-
mann, Ekblad, & Orley, 1994; Miller & Rasco, 2004;
Mollica, Pole, Son, Murray, & Tor, 1997; Reyes & Jacobs,
2006; van der Kolk, McFarlane, & Weisaeth, 1996; Wilson
& Drozdek, 2004) in the low- and middle-income countries
where most disasters strike. Prominent sources of suffering
include attack, losses of home and loved ones, displace-
ment, family separation, gender-based violence, and expo-
sure to myriad protection issues such as recruitment into
armed groups and trafficking.
A decade ago, mental health and psychosocial supports
in international emergencies were relegated to the humani-
tarian ghetto and seen as things to be done after the “real”
humanitarian work of saving lives had been completed.
This has changed as public awareness of the aftermath of
emergencies has increased, and psychosocial supports have
become familiar fixtures in the humanitarian response to
disasters. More than any other single event, the 2004 Asian
tsunami brought home to people worldwide the enormity
of the psychosocial needs that emergencies create.
The expanded awareness of the importance of psychoso-
cial intervention has brought an expansion of psychosocial
interventions. Many practitioners, myself included, regard
this as a positive development, because there is increasing
evidence of the efficacy of psychosocial interventions in
addressing issues of trauma (e.g., Barbanel & Sternberg,
2006; Carll, 2007; Green et al., 2003), depression (Bolton
et al., 2007), family separation (Hepburn, 2006), recruit-
ment (Betancourt et al., 2008), and related issues and in
promoting resilience and positive coping by survivors and
communities (e.g., Barber, 2009).
At the same time, practitioners increasingly recognize
that there are risks involved with psychosocial interven-
tions that may lead to unintentional harm (Anderson, 1999;
Inter-Agency Standing Committee [IASC], 2007; Wessells,
2008). Here is a small sampling of do no harm violations I
have seen in various countries.
Editor’s Note
Michael G. Wessells received the International Humanitar-
ian Award. Award winners are invited to deliver an award
address at the APA’s annual convention. A version of this
award address was delivered at the 117th annual meeting,
held August 6–9, 2009, in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Arti-
cles based on award addresses are reviewed, but they dif-
fer from unsolicited articles in that they are expressions of
the winners’ reflections on their work and their views of
the field.
842 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
In 1996 in Rwanda, orphans from the 1994 genocide
were placed in small orphanages or centers, many of which
were funded by Western groups, including churches, who
wanted to provide care and protection for unaccompanied
and separated children. An unfortunate and unanticipated
consequence was that the centers contributed to family sep-
aration, as mothers desperate to support their babies aban-
doned the babies on the orphanages’ doorsteps.
In 1999 in Tirana, Albania, where camps filled with Kos-
sovar survivors of Serb attacks, an American psychologist
had set up a tent for counseling women survivors of rape.
For a woman to have entered the tent would have identi-
fied herself as a survivor of rape, which many families re-
gard as a stain on family honor that must be rectified by
killing the survivor.
In 2002 in rural Sierra Leone, international nongovern-
mental organizations (NGOs) worked after the war to sup-
port the reintegration of formerly recruited children. Unfor-
tunately, most programs privileged former boy combatants,
despite the fact that large numbers of girls had also been
recruited (McKay & Mazurana, 2004; Wessells, 2006).
This gender discrimination was itself a significant source of
structural violence and psychosocial distress.
The longer one’s engagement in humanitarian work, the
greater one’s appreciation of its complexity, the potential
for harm, and the need to address a number of important
issues. These include contextual insensitivity to the cul-
tural, structural, and political aspects of emergency situa-
tions; excessive focus on deficits such as mental health
problems without sufficient attention to resilience and cop-
ing; overreliance on individualistic approaches; power
abuses such as the imposition of outsider approaches; and
the provision of inadequate training and supervision for
staff, among others.
It is an understatement to say that there is a shortage of
easy answers to countless ethical questions. To obtain ethi-
cal guidance, practitioners often turn to professional codes
such as the American Psychological Association (APA)
Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct
(APA, 2002; hereafter referred to as the Code of Ethics).
Although these codes do offer some useful guidance, they
are typically written around general principles and seldom
consider the specific, highly sensitive issues that arise in
contexts of humanitarian emergencies. This lack of speci-
ficity makes it very difficult to define what constitutes ethi-
cal and appropriate practice in international emergencies.
There is also inadequate research and training. The pau-
city of research on which interventions work in large-scale
international emergencies (Batniji, Van Ommeren, & Sara-
ceno, 2006; Betancourt & Williams, 2008; Wessells & van
Ommeren, 2008) has enabled an “anything goes” atmo-
sphere. This is exacerbated by a lack of appropriate train-
ing. Many doctorate-level psychologists trained in North
American and European universities lack the cultural, hu-
manitarian, and other competencies needed to do responsi-
ble, contextually appropriate psychosocial work in large-
scale emergencies. Because of these factors, it is not
uncommon for psychosocial interventions in emergencies
to violate the do no harm imperative that is a cornerstone
of the principle of beneficence.
In this article, I identify some of the primary do no
harm issues that have surfaced repeatedly in my global
work responding to armed conflicts as well as natural di-
sasters. I write not from a high moral ground of assuming
“I would never cause harm!” but from a humbler,
grounded perspective that recognizes that all interventions
(and even one’s presence) in emergencies have unintended
consequences, including negative ones. Because emergen-
cies are fluid, potentially volatile, and riddled with uncer-
tainties and complexities, it is relatively easy even for sea-
soned practitioners to cause harm. Still, much harm can be
avoided through awareness; appropriate preparation and
ethical standards; and a critical, reflective stance. This arti-
cle is written in the spirit of enabling the awareness and
critical reflection needed to prevent harm. Admittedly, it
does not provide exhaustive coverage of this essential
topic.
An important caveat is that what counts as a harmful
practice is in the eye of the beholder. Indeed, the identifi-
cation of harmful practices and judgments about the bal-
ance of positive or negative effects of particular practices
reflects one’s values as well as technical considerations.
The question Whose values matter most? is salient because
the values of humanitarians often collide with those of the
affected population. To manage this issue, I focus on fre-
quently occurring practices that have been identified as
problematic not only by Western psychologists but also by
national psychosocial workers in diverse contexts. Al-
though the emphasis here is on unintentional harm caused
by U.S. psychologists, the key points apply to all psycholo-
gists and people who conduct psychosocial work in emer-
gency settings. Because many of these people are not psy-
chologists but psychiatrists, social workers, or trained
paraprofessionals, I speak broadly of the unintended harm
caused by psychosocial workers.
Insensitivity to Emergency Contexts and Systems
In emergency settings, one often encounters well-meaning
U.S. psychologists who have no experience in international
emergencies, little understanding of the local culture or
context, and no relationships with the agencies or people in
the affected areas. Although the psychologists are nobly
motivated by the feeling that “I just had to come and
help,” this approach has been described as “disaster tour-
ism” or “parachuting” rather than as professional humani-
tarian response.
843November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
Parachuting
Parachuting refers to the arrival of Western or outside
“helpers” who have ongoing relations with neither relief
efforts or agencies nor the affected population. Parachuting
creates a number of problems. For example, it uses scarce
resources such as food and water that might better go to
affected people or to seasoned humanitarian responders. In
addition, it is not uncommon for parachuters to violate cul-
tural and social norms by, for example, flaunting alcohol in
a society that regards such drinking as corrupt or dressing
in ways that national people regard as immoral. Such cul-
turally inappropriate behavior can dim local people’s recep-
tivity to the presence of outsiders when outsiders’ help is
needed.
Parachuters cause harm in myriad other ways, such as
by using culturally inappropriate methods; by violating se-
curity precautions; by using aggressive methods that pick
people open but then leave them vulnerable and without
appropriate follow-up; by providing short-term support that
raises expectations and leaves people feeling abandoned
when the parachuters leave; and by failing to coordinate
their work with related efforts. Parachuting is based on a
misconception that outside psychologists should assume a
role of providing direct services. Such a role is inadvisable,
especially in light of their general lack of knowledge about
the culture, sociohistoric context, and current situation.
However, even experienced psychosocial workers may
cause harm through the inappropriate management of con-
textual issues.
Personal and Collective Security
Many psychologists enter emergencies with little under-
standing of the security context or necessary precautions
and with similarly low levels of awareness of the implica-
tions of their presence. Although security issues may be
presented in terms of personal safety, their ethical implica-
tions extend far beyond individuals. For example, the pres-
ence of a U.S. citizen in a place such as Afghanistan is
viewed by many people as a political act, and U.S. human-
itarians have been targeted increasingly since 2001. Al-
though a U.S. psychologist may decide to hazard personal
injury, that decision does not address the wider risk that a
U.S. citizen’s injury or death will curtail humanitarian ef-
forts, depriving local people of much-needed support. In
addition, making clear-eyed decisions about security is
hampered by the burnout, depression, substance abuse, and
other problems that burden humanitarians on a significant
scale (Ehrenreich, 2006).
Aid as a Weapon
A key feature of emergency contexts is the power dynam-
ics among various groups in a local setting (Anderson,
1999; Wessells, 1999). Humanitarian aid can become a
political tool when it is used to increase the power of some
groups over others. For instance, in the refugee camps in
Goma after the 1994 Rwandan genocide, particular groups
seized power and controlled the humanitarian aid, using it
as a means of advancing their own political agenda (Pren-
dergast, 1996). Psychologists who are unaware of such dy-
namics may inadvertently have their presence and support
politicized and used in ways that favor some groups of
people over others.
Even in less dramatic cases, psychologists who do not
understand local power dynamics may inadvertently sup-
port discrimination and other sources of harm. For exam-
ple, psychosocial workers typically begin their work in a
camp or village with a process of consultation and open
community dialogues. Although the attempt may be to es-
tablish an open, participatory approach, local structures of
power and authority may undermine genuine participation.
Each local group has a power structure in which some peo-
ple enjoy voice and privileges that are denied to others.
Typically, there are particular people who are kept hidden
away by prior orders from elite power brokers or by un-
spoken rules. In many communities, the poorest of the poor
and people with disabilities are expected not to participate.
Psychologists who are seduced by the rhetoric of inclusiv-
ity and romanticized images of community may find that
there was no real participation by the people most in need
of support. In this manner, psychosocial work in emergen-
cies can serve to replicate social injustices that had been
prevalent before the emergency or that had even caused it
or exacerbated its negative impacts.
Raised Expectations
One of the greatest ethical issues in humanitarian emergen-
cies is raised expectations. Typically, these arise less from
false promises than from contextual considerations such as
divergent perceptions of psychosocial workers and affected
people. For example, an important first step in psychoso-
cial work is to conduct a situation assessment and deter-
mine whether and how to intervene. Feeling desperate for
help, however, the affected people may view the arrival of
an outside psychosocial worker as a sign that aid is at hand
and that there will soon be many improvements in their
situation. Making matters worse, the assessment visit may
not bring immediate benefits. Typically, assessments are
conducted in part to provide agencies with data that are
needed to develop grant proposals, the review of which
may take months. Such long delays without action that
benefits survivors often leave affected people feeling frus-
trated, resentful, and worse off than they had been before
the psychosocial workers’ visit. To prevent such harm,
many practitioners work within a framework of rapid as-
sessment and rapid response, following data collection with
tangible supports even on a limited scale.
844 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
Poor Coordination
Poor coordination is the Achilles’ heel of most emergen-
cies (Minear, 2002), which occasion a massive influx of
NGOs and humanitarians who provide urgent support yet
often fail to harmonize their efforts. For example, many
NGOs conduct psychosocial assessments without coordina-
tion, leading to duplicate assessments and raised expecta-
tions. The resulting assessment fatigue generates frustration
and resentment, undermining the trust and partnership
needed to build strong psychosocial supports. Uneven allo-
cation of support is also an issue. Often, people in rural
areas, where the need may be greatest, receive little sup-
port while the residents of the capital city receive much
attention. Poor coordination enables this problem, which
may receive little attention or action.
The coordination of mental health and psychosocial sup-
ports is particularly difficult because of institutionalized
divisions in the field. In most emergencies, psychologists’
work develops in two independent streams (Betancourt et
al., 2008; Galappatti, 2003; Wessells & van Ommeren,
2008). First is mental health work conducted by clinicians,
typically in the health sector, for the most severely affected
people. The second is holistic, community-based psychoso-
cial work, typically conducted in the protection sector, that
supports a larger number of people through the activities of
trained paraprofessionals and community members. Al-
though these approaches are complementary and serve the
wider good when coordinated, they often tend to develop
in isolation. For example, in Kosovo in 1999, two separate
coordination groups formed and failed to coordinate with
each other: Neither one knew the other existed. Such poor
coordination thwarts referrals for severely affected people
or efforts to ensure the provision of comprehensive sup-
ports.
Many psychologists are poorly prepared to coordinate
their work because they have little understanding of the
international humanitarian system. Within this system,
emergency aid is increasingly delivered through a sys-
tem of twelve clusters, including the Health Cluster and
the Protection Cluster. These two clusters have a joint
responsibility for coordinating work on mental health
and psychosocial support in the affected country (IASC,
2007), working closely with the government, interna-
tional NGOs, and civil society actors. Key obligations of
emergency psychosocial workers are to understand the
emergency system, participate regularly in coordination
group meetings, and work collaboratively toward the
comprehensive, quality supports to which affected peo-
ple are entitled. Understanding the workings of the in-
ternational humanitarian system is an important part of
training for any psychosocial worker who intends to
work internationally.
Contextually Inappropriate Interventions
The chaos of large emergencies, together with the lack of
research on effective interventions that was discussed
above, helps to create an anything goes atmosphere condu-
cive to the use of interventions of questionable value or the
use of interventions that are inappropriate to the context.
For example, the use of individual counseling may be inap-
propriate if participation in counseling brands one as a vic-
tim of a particular rights violation such as rape, thereby
causing severe stigma and possibly even additional as-
saults. Individual counseling is also ill-advised in collective
societies that honor group over individual well-being and
in which participation in individual counseling could lead
to social isolation and criticism at a moment when support
is needed.
Furthermore, counseling methods in general place sig-
nificant emphasis on disclosing feelings and personal infor-
mation, which may be useful in some contexts. The disclo-
sure of distress, however, is inappropriate in some cultures,
particularly if negative disclosures reflect badly on one’s
family (Lee & Sue, 2001). Moreover, talking about one’s
experiences can be harmful in some contexts. In rural An-
gola, teenagers who had been recruited into armed groups
and who had killed people were viewed as spiritually con-
taminated or haunted by the angry spirits of the people
they had killed. Local people see these spirits as enor-
mously powerful and capable of causing illness in one’s
family or crop failures in the community. To treat this af-
fliction, traditional healers conduct purification rituals de-
signed to clean the young people of the angry spirits (Wes-
sells & Monteiro, 2004). At the end of the ritual, the healer
often tells the young former recruits, “Don’t look back,”
because talking about the ritual or one’s experiences is be-
lieved to bring the angry spirits back.
An intervention that is often used inappropriately in
large-scale international emergencies is critical incident
stress debriefing (CISD; see Everly & Mitchell, 1999).
Trained CISD facilitators try to reduce traumatic stress by
helping survivors talk about their feelings and responses to
traumatic incidents, to the point of describing the events in
great detail. Although some evidence suggests the useful-
ness of this intervention in large-scale emergencies, other
studies have failed to confirm its efficacy (e.g., Thabet,
Vostanis, & Karim, 2005). There is also evidence that de-
briefing impairs natural recovery after traumatic exposures
(see Mukherjee & Alpert, 2006, for a review). It is impor-
tant to note that the problem with inappropriate interven-
tions often resides less with the method itself than with its
inappropriate use. Unfortunately, in most emergencies,
there are no ethics boards or potent means of regulating
practice. Without sanctions for harmful practices, do no
harm issues may proliferate rapidly.
845November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
Individualistic Versus Systems Orientation
Western psychology is well-known for its individualistic
orientation and its corresponding focus on the well-being
of at-risk individuals and groups. This orientation, how-
ever, is poorly suited to address the scale of human suffer-
ing in emergencies. In recent emergencies such as the
floods in Myanmar, the conflicts in Iraq and the Demo-
cratic Republic of Congo, and the political violence in Kenya,
hundreds of thousands of people or more have endured multi-
ple losses, displacement, and profound suffering and need
psychosocial support. Beyond individuals, these emergencies
damage or destroy physical and social support systems on a
massive scale. When addressing such large-scale, systemic
issues, it is important to organize an equally holistic, systemic
humanitarian response. Exclusive focus on individuals gets the
humanitarian response off on the wrong foot and can lead to
superficial approaches to obtaining informed consent and the
development of programs that target particular groups of peo-
ple excessively and fail to provide holistic supports.
Informed Consent Issues
Informed consent is a cornerstone principle of ethical prac-
tice. If obtaining informed consent is always complex, the
complexities are amplified considerably in emergencies,
many of which occur in areas having low rates of literacy.
In some cultures, problems with language and communica-
tion can make it difficult to ensure informed consent, as
Western concepts often have no exact translation or do not
fit the local context. Obtaining written consent can be even
trickier in war zones, because people may be suspicious of
written documents, which they fear may be used against
them. In addition, norms of hospitality may mitigate
against saying “no.”
Underlying informed consent are two key assumptions:
that people are autonomous and that people have access to
all of the information needed about the implications of
their participation (Fisher et al., 2002; Mackenzie, McDow-
ell, & Pittaway, 2007). Both assumptions are tenuous in
most emergency contexts. People in collectivist societies
often put the good of the group above their own individual
good and may be willing to endure excessive individual
risk to help others. They may not regard their decisions as
autonomous because they analyze the situation through the
prism of their relationships and a web of hidden expecta-
tions, roles, and power dynamics. The decision whether
and how to relate to outsiders is potentially very important
to a group of affected people because of people’s despera-
tion in emergency settings. Saying “no” to an outsider, for
example, may be perceived by local people as reducing the
chances that the village or group will receive needed assis-
tance. Local norms may dictate that important decisions are
not made individually but through the appropriate system
of leaders and relationships. If the chiefs or elders encour-
age everyone to help the outsider, it may become very dif-
ficult or impossible to say “no.”
The second assumption, that prospective participants
have the information needed to make informed decisions,
is dubious in war zones, which are inherently fluid and
unpredictable (Hart & Tyrer, 2006; Mackenzie et al.,
2007). For refugees who have just spilled across a border,
it may be impossible to know what tomorrow will bring.
One-off collections of informed consent hold little validity
in such a context. A preferred approach is to view in-
formed consent as an iterative process in which there is
renegotiation in light of changing circumstances and new
information about the potential risks and benefits of partici-
pation. Unfortunately, many of the institutional review
boards that are charged with ethics review in the United
States have little experience in emergency settings and may
be satisfied with a one-off informed consent process be-
cause that is appropriate in most Western contexts. A use-
ful complement to institutional review board reviews is
review by local ethics gatekeepers, who might include reli-
gious leaders, community leaders, respected women, youth,
or national university professors. However, these reviews,
too, may be biased by a variety of agendas.
Excessive Targeting
Because most war zones contain large numbers of affected
people yet have scarce resources for psychosocial support,
many donors and practitioners focus resources and pro-
grams on particularly vulnerable groups. Nowhere is this
practice more widespread than in regard to former child
soldiers, many of whom have suffered extensively and all
of whom have had their rights violated (Wessells, 2006).
After many armed conflicts, governments and international
NGOs regularly organize psychosocial and reintegration
programs that aim to rehabilitate formerly recruited chil-
dren and to enable them to find a place in civilian life.
Typically, these programs entail counseling and peer group
supports, family reunification, mentoring, access to educa-
tion and livelihoods, spiritual cleansing where that is indi-
cated, and protection against re-recruitment.
Although the need to support former child soldiers is
indisputable, programs that focus exclusively or exces-
sively on formerly recruited children often cause significant
harm by stigmatizing them. Not uncommonly, former child
soldiers enjoy better access to food, medicines, and other
necessities than do the people whom they had attacked.
After the recent war in Liberia, local people decried the
excessive targeting of cash and aid for formerly recruited
children as blood money and wondered why equivalent
supports were not extended to all war-affected young peo-
ple. Similarly, in Sierra Leone, returning former child sol-
diers, well-dressed because of foreign aid administered as
part of programs on disarmament, demobilization, and rein-
tegration, often found that their arrival in their home vil-
846 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
lages triggered jealousies that led to reverse stigmatization
and social tensions within the community. For these rea-
sons, the recently developed Paris Principles (UNICEF,
2007) caution against targeting support for formerly re-
cruited children and recommend the provision of simulta-
neous supports for all war-affected children.
Nonholistic Supports
Most seasoned emergency practitioners (e.g., Jacobs, 2007;
Prewitt Diaz, 2008) take a public health approach that em-
bodies systems theory and seeks to address population
needs. Such an approach recognizes not only individual
needs but also the importance of intertwined social ecolo-
gies such as families, communities, and societies (Boothby,
Strang, & Wessells, 2006; Bronfenbrenner, 1979; Masten
& Obradović, 2007). Quality intervention entails meeting
the holistic needs of affected populations by working at
multiple levels such as the household, community, and so-
cietal levels and by strengthening social supports. The lat-
ter is a key theme in the main guidelines for the field, the
IASC Guidelines on Mental Health and Psychosocial Sup-
port in Emergency Settings (IASC, 2007), hereafter re-
ferred to as the IASC Guidelines.
In contrast, less experienced emergency practitioners
tend to take a narrow, clinical approach that does not ad-
dress multisectoral needs. Indeed, many psychologists who
enter emergencies with a focus on trauma, depression, and
anxiety aim to support the most severely affected people
using tools such as individual counseling and cognitive
behavioral therapy. Although these supports have a place,
they often run counter to local cultural norms. More worri-
some, these psychologists typically fail to recognize that
affected people often identify as their greatest sources of
distress not the memories of past violence and horrific
events but the problems of everyday living (Barber, 2001;
Boyden & Mann, 2005; Miller & Fernando, 2008; Sum-
merfield, 2001; Wessells & van Ommeren, 2008). These
include insecurity, living in overcrowded camps without
privacy, or lacking the livelihoods needed to obtain neces-
sities such as food and health care. Psychological services
such as counseling cannot address these needs, which war-
rant a wider, multidisciplinary approach that is beyond the
training and orientation of many psychologists.
Recognizing the need for a holistic, systems approach,
the IASC Guidelines call for a layered system of supports
as enshrined in the intervention pyramid. The base of the
pyramid, which benefits the largest number of people, is
the establishment of security and provision of access to
basic services such as food, water, shelter, and health care.
Access to these things alleviates significant distress and
allows the nonformal psychosocial supports that are extant
in the affected population to take effect. The second layer
consists of family and community supports that help to
address the separations, disruptions, and dislocations that
have occurred. Commonly used supports include family
reunification, community action projects to address needs
such as health and education, and support for women’s and
youth groups that aid and empower affected people. The
third layer consists of focused, nonspecialized supports that
help particular groups of affected people. For example,
survivors of gender-based violence typically need support
in accessing the health system, interacting with the police,
and managing community issues such as stigma and social
isolation. The top layer consists of specialized supports for
people who have been severely affected, including those
who had preexisting problems and who are unable to func-
tion. This system of supports should include mechanisms
for referral and should be implemented not only by exter-
nal actors but also by national actors such as community
leaders, government agencies, and community-based orga-
nizations.
This multileveled system is often missing in emergen-
cies, and psychosocial workers have done too little to cor-
rect the problem. As a result, in many emergencies, one
sees either of two extremes, both of which are harmful. For
example, in Bosnia during the wars of the former Yugosla-
via, there was a surplus of clinically oriented work yet a
paucity of the community-based work needed to support
the larger population. In northern Uganda, which until
2006 had suffered repeated attacks and mass displacements
by the so-called Lord’s Resistance Army, the opposite
problem existed. Extensive community-based supports were
available, yet few channels existed for the referral of se-
verely affected people. Either situation causes gaps that
leave significant numbers of war-affected people without
the comprehensive supports that are needed.
Often, these asymmetries of coverage are accompanied
by stereotypes that cause additional harm. In many emer-
gencies, there is a tendency to speak of mass trauma and to
portray everyone as traumatized. This depiction not only
pathologizes normal reactions to life-threatening events but
also reduces to medical terms conditions that have complex
political, historical, cultural, and social roots (Punamaki,
1989). Equally problematic is the opposite kind of stereo-
type of everyone as resilient, which can distract attention
from survivors who have been severely affected and enable
governments to dodge their responsibility to provide essen-
tial mental health services. It is vital to remember that war-
affected people is not a homogeneous category: Their dif-
ferences are as great as their similarities and warrant a
holistic, multilayered response.
Deficits and Resilience
Because emergencies create dire human needs and shatter
human rights, many psychosocial workers focus on psycho-
logical deficits such as mental illness, posttraumatic stress
disorder, and substance abuse as well as social problems
such as stigma, discrimination, social isolation, and break-
847November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
down of social controls and supports. However, an exclu-
sive or excessive focus on deficits often enables or contrib-
utes directly to harm.
The Deficits Trap
The emphasis on deficits is visible in many emergencies in
psychologists’ epidemiological studies of the prevalence of
posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, or locally defined
maladies. This epidemiological focus is valuable because
systematic data are needed to guide psychosocial program-
ming. However, the exclusive focus on deficits frequently
creates a biased picture that limits program alternatives,
supports stereotypes of people as helpless victims, and re-
flects the researchers’ biases rather than the complex reali-
ties at hand.
The primary bias is the underestimation of resilience,
which occurs in diverse contexts (Bonano, 2004; Boothby,
Crawford, & Halperin, 2006; Masten, 2001; Masten & Ob-
radović, 2007; Wessells, 2006). Significant numbers of
emergency-affected people exhibit remarkable resilience in
that they function well despite adversity, do not experience
profound suffering, and cope reasonably well with their
problems of living. In my experience, resilience is the un-
told story of emergencies, and it is seldom addressed by
researchers and workers conducting assessments. Striking
an appropriate balance between deficits and resilience is a
high priority in emergencies.
The deficits focus frequently creates an excessively bad
picture, which can blunt the hopes of survivors at a mo-
ment when hope is desperately needed. The exclusive em-
phasis on negatives often encourages stereotypes of every-
one as traumatized or as damaged goods. One of the great
sources of harm in the humanitarian world is that agencies
frequently exploit negative images for purposes of raising
funds. Typically, survivors perceive such images as dehu-
manizing and humiliating, and as such the images suffocate
hope.
Furthermore, the excessive focus on deficits distracts
attention from the resources and assets that exist in any
group of affected people and support resilience. Emergency
survivors may have nonformal supports such as families,
friends, and neighbors, and they may have formal supports
such as traditional social organizations or organized com-
munity and government services. Too often, a deficits fo-
cus steers psychological workers conducting assessments
away from asking fundamental questions, such as “What
supports already exist?” and “What strategies are people
using to cope with their difficult circumstances?” Answer-
ing these questions is essential for developing effective
programs, which should build on extant supports, assets,
and resources. A challenge to psychology is to overcome
the current emphasis on a deficits model, because psycho-
social workers with strong preconceptions are not in a
good position either to pose such questions or to listen in a
spirit of openmindedness and learning from local people.
Indeed, for many humanitarians, a key question that ought
to be asked is “How well are we listening?”
Victimhood and Empowerment
Emergency-affected people are often described as victims.
Used judiciously, this language of victimhood is potentially
useful in engaging international legal protections and ab-
solving survivors of rape and other horrors of any felt re-
sponsibility for the assaults and bad things they have suf-
fered. However, there is a widespread tendency to refer to
all emergency-affected people as victims, an appellation
that can leave people feeling helpless and paralyzed, creat-
ing a self-fulfilling prophecy. For example, in East Timor
after the 1999 attacks by Indonesian paramilitaries, I
worked with Timorese staff of a child-focused agency. A
doctor had told the staff that they were all traumatized vic-
tims and had left without providing any psychosocial sup-
port. Having taken on the identity and role of victims, they
sat listlessly and explained why they could not possibly
help children in their overwhelmed condition. Through em-
powerment-focused activities, most demonstrated signifi-
cant improvements in well-being and social interactions
over the next several weeks and successfully organized
activities to support children. They said that part of their
transition was due to thinking of themselves not as victims
but as survivors who have capacities and agency. An im-
portant lesson is that people often reconstruct their identity
as victims after horrendous events, yet victims are not in a
good position to take charge of their recovery and future.
In other settings, I have observed that the victims label
makes people feel demeaned and shamed by their experi-
ences at a moment when the restoration of their dignity is
a high priority (IASC, 2002). To avoid such problems,
most seasoned practitioners use the victims label sparingly,
emphasize that affected people are survivors, and help to
build the sense of self-help that enables people to recover
and function well after overwhelming experiences (Hobfoll
et al., 2007). The emphasis on emergency-affected people
as survivors fits with a resilience approach (Bonano, 2004)
that emphasizes the importance of self-help, social mobili-
zation, and collective empowerment (Beristain, 1999; Ja-
cobs, 2007; Wessells, 1999, 2007). As highlighted in the
IASC Guidelines, these are the foundations of effective
emergency response.
Capacity Building and Sustainability
The philosophy behind sustainability is embodied in the
proverb “Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day;
teach a man to fish and you feed him for a lifetime.” This
empowerment approach of building the capacities of af-
fected people contrasts starkly with the reality that at the
end of many emergency psychosocial programs, the NGOs
that had organized them leave little behind. It is common-
848 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
place to see psychologists and other humanitarians rush
into emergencies and set up programs funded by soft
money. When the funding dries up and the CNN cameras
have moved on to the next crisis, the programs promptly
collapse. Meanwhile, the NGOs and UN agencies rush to
the next emergency, only to repeat the same pattern.
In addition to not providing the long-term support that
emergencies warrant, this short-term approach may cause
harm by raising expectations of longer-term support and
then leaving affected people feeling abandoned. As the
short-term relief teams pour in (a phenomenon people in
Sri Lanka called “the second tsunami”), people may be-
come dependent on outsiders for support, thereby causing
or setting the stage for additional harm.
Dependency
Dependency causes harm in multiple ways. It robs people
of dignity and contributes to a sense of helplessness that is
the antithesis of self-help and empowerment. Worse yet,
dependency may actually undermine the preexisting sup-
ports of affected people. For example, in tsunami-affected
Sri Lanka, a village of 50 families that had never had
NGOs present had 27 different NGOs offering or providing
help a year after the tsunami. One villager commented that
people previously had turned to neighbors and relatives for
help whereas a year post-tsunami they depended on the
NGOs (IASC, 2007).
Eager to implement supports on an urgent basis and
wanting to bypass government bureaucracies and politics,
NGOs often create dependency by setting up their own
systems of mental health and psychosocial support inde-
pendent of government systems. The creation of parallel
systems may weaken government capacities by draining
away important resources such as skilled psychosocial
workers and can further erode government credibility and
legitimacy. Also, these parallel systems tend to be unsus-
tainable. An important question, then, for psychologists to
ask in regard to their humanitarian work is “How am I
helping to facilitate long-term supports for affected peo-
ple?” Practically, the strongest approach to creating sus-
tainable supports is to build on and strengthen supports
that are already present and to institutionalize them within
the government structures and nonformal systems.
Inadequate Preparation
Poorly trained psychosocial workers—a significant source
of supports of poor quality—are a widespread problem in
humanitarian response. Nowhere is this more visible than
in regard to the quest for “instant counselors.” In 2005,
after the Asian tsunami, the Sri Lankan government
planned to train in several weeks a cadre of 10,000 coun-
selors, each of whom would then fan out and conduct a
single counseling session with 100 tsunami-affected people.
Fortunately, the plan was shelved as a result of criticism.
Nevertheless, the practice of inadequate training for
counselors in emergency-affected countries remains a com-
mon problem. Too often, NGOs conduct short-term train-
ing and provide little supervision and ongoing follow-up
support for psychosocial workers. Inadequate training often
occurs through training-of-trainer approaches in which skill
levels become progressively diluted the farther one goes
down the training cascade and in which there is little moni-
toring of quality of supports provided or ongoing mentor-
ing and support for the trainees.
The Trouble With Silos
The importance of long-term training that includes appropriate
provisions for quality of support notwithstanding, training and
capacity-building efforts often cause harm through the cre-
ation of vertical silos for the delivery of psychosocial support.
A common error throughout Africa and Asia is to provide
in-depth training for trauma counselors, who conduct their
work independent of the wider health sector and mental health
system. This practice fragments systems of care by creating
separate silos, which often do not communicate or coordinate
with each other. An extreme example of this has occurred in
some situations having high rates of gender-based violence,
where well-intentioned practitioners have created psychosocial
support for rape survivors only. Beyond stigmatization, such a
siloed approach leads to poor utilization of scarce resources,
when the emphasis in any emergency setting should be to
build back better by helping to establish sustainable, inte-
grated systems of health and mental health care.
A related error is the tendency to put mental health and
psychosocial support in a separate silo, even in a separate
sector, by building capacities only for focused psychosocial
support. To be sure, significant need exists for focused psy-
chosocial supports that address the needs of severely af-
fected people and provide nonformal psychosocial supports
for people who are functional yet distressed. However, psy-
chosocial support is a cross-cutting issue because the way
in which aid is organized in various humanitarian sectors
affects the psychosocial well-being of survivors (IASC,
2007). For example, refugees often report that overcrowd-
ing and lack of privacy are among their greatest sources of
distress. These sources of distress are preventable if emer-
gency shelters are designed with an eye toward protecting
people’s psychosocial well-being. To provide comprehen-
sive supports, psychologists should avoid narrow capacity-
building silos that train only psychologists or psychosocial
workers. Indeed, emergencies require that psychologists get
out of their box and build intersectoral capacities for sup-
porting people’s well-being.
Power and External Imposition
In international emergencies, Western psychology has
much to offer, particularly when it is blended with local,
culturally grounded supports (Wessells & Monteiro,
849November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
2001, 2004). However, many psychologists rush in and
train nationals on the Western-derived approaches and
tools that they know best without adequate attention to
the possibilities of causing harm. In fact, the enormous
power asymmetry between humanitarians and affected
people, not to mention between doctorate-level psychol-
ogists and national psychosocial workers, makes it a
challenge to avoid causing harm through the imposition
of outsider supports and a concomitant weakening of
valuable indigenous supports.
In 1997, during Sierra Leone’s bloody war, I worked
with teams of Sierra Leoneans who had been trained by
American psychologists and social workers to focus on
trauma and provide counseling for traumatized people. Ea-
ger to receive the support of a Western psychologist and
ashamed of their own traditional culture, national staff and
local war-affected people denied initially that they had cul-
tural practices such as cleansing rituals to help support sur-
vivors. Subsequently, when more trust had been established
and an Angolan psychologist had spoken on the importance
of cultural practices in her country, numerous healers, lead-
ers, and affected people disclosed that they did have valu-
able cultural practices related to healing and reconciliation
(Wessells, 2006, 2009). They subsequently admitted that
they had initially concealed these practices out of concern
over appearing backward, a desire to please the Western
psychologist, and hope that outsider methods would be
beneficial. In essence, their self-silencing had marginalized
their own cultural practices. Unaware of this trap, many
psychologists start not by asking how local people under-
stand their situation and how they customarily obtain sup-
port but by teaching their own methods of support, which
may have no basis in the local culture. In this manner, psy-
chology may become a tool of neocolonialism (Dawes &
Cairns, 1998; Wessells, 1999). A key for psychologists in
international humanitarian work, then, is to avoid the arro-
gance of power and make humility and learning from local
people central parts of their practice.
An important caveat regards the importance of not ro-
manticizing cultural practices, as may occur when the de-
sire for cultural sensitivity dominates critical thinking. The
fact that some cultural practices are harmful is evident in
most societies. For example, in Sierra Leone, female geni-
tal cutting (circumcision) is widespread, yet few outside
practitioners support that practice. In building on local sup-
ports, then, it is crucial to maintain a critical attitude and
use international human rights standards as benchmarks for
deciding which cultural practices are supportable.
Prevention
Humanitarian response in emergencies is notoriously reac-
tive and ephemeral, and it is constantly at risk of applying
band-aids rather than addressing underlying structural prob-
lems. In the acute phase, when funds are available and the
sense of urgency is high, masses of humanitarians and
NGOs pour in and conduct emergency work. A year or so
later, after the acute phase, the humanitarian agencies rush
on to the next crisis, despite the fact that there remain ex-
tensive needs and too few supports at the site of the previ-
ous crisis.
This crisis-chasing approach constitutes a massive fail-
ure of prevention and causes untold harm. Whereas the
crisis-chasing approach waits for the disasters to occur and
then tries to pick up the pieces and provide support, a pre-
vention approach would recognize that some of the worst
impacts of disasters are preventable and take steps to miti-
gate harm. For example, in floods, the most vulnerable
people are often the deeply impoverished people who live
on hills prone to mudslides. In this case, the term natural
disaster is a misnomer. Humanitarian emphasis on respon-
sive action should be coupled with commensurate efforts to
prevent harm through disaster risk reduction and emer-
gency preparation. Indeed, training people to be prepared
for emergencies is an important part of reestablishing a
sense of security in emergency-prone areas. Furthermore,
human-caused disasters such as armed conflicts often have
their roots in social or political exclusion, which is to some
extent preventable. Addressing social injustice and other
structural causes of political violence is a powerful means
of preventing emergencies and an essential component of
humanitarian work.
A key part of prevention is protection, defined broadly
to include the reduction of risks of all forms of exploitation
and abuse and the strengthening of systems of protection.
An important element of protection systems is the estab-
lishment of community child protection committees during
emergencies to monitor, report on, and address protection
threats (Wessells, in press). For example, in northern Af-
ghanistan after the defeat of the Taliban in 2001, young
women suffered as a result of forced early marriage, as
economic hardship led families to give their daughters into
marriage at progressively younger ages. In Badakshan
Province, suicide rates increased as girls as young as 11 or
12 years of age threw themselves off of bridges to avoid
being forced to marry 55-year-old men. Community child
protection committees reduced this problem by working
closely with local imams (religious leaders), who realized
that making girls marry at age 11 was not traditional prac-
tice and caused harm. In numerous cases, imams convened
community dialogues in which people decided communally
to ban such early marriages. These bans produced steep
and immediate reductions in the suicide rates and the
forced early marriages, as the average marriage age rose to
15 years. This example illustrates how community-based
social protection can support psychosocial well-being by
preventing harmful practices.
In emergencies, great need exists for psychologists to
not only apply their traditional tools but also support sys-
850 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
tems of protection, which decrease abuse, reduce feelings
of insecurity, and enhance people’s well-being. Because
protection and psychosocial support go hand in hand, psy-
chologists should integrate protection components into all
of their capacity-building efforts. A key way of doing this
is to simultaneously remove or mitigate risks and
strengthen the protective factors that support positive cop-
ing and resilience (Rutter, 1979, 1985).
Conclusion
Psychosocial workers encounter myriad do no harm issues
in international emergencies, and the issues discussed
above are by no means comprehensive. However, the di-
versity and severity of these issues should not be cause for
inaction or excessive uncertainty about how to respond.
That these and related problems are preventable or man-
ageable is evident in the strong, contextually appropriate,
and effective psychosocial work that psychologists, com-
munities, agencies, and governments are doing in diverse
countries and regions.
Broadly, there are four ways of preventing or minimizing
violations of the do no harm imperative. Foremost among
these is critical reflection on ethical issues before, during, and
after each emergency response and on ways of preventing or
minimizing them. Not only individual humanitarians but also
agencies, coordinating bodies, and members of affected popu-
lations should engage in this critical reflection. A useful prac-
tice is to compare the views of outside psychosocial workers
and local people, who may have divergent ideas of what the
most significant ethical issues are and what constitute proper
ways of handling them. Ideally, the reflection process itself
should respect local people and avoid domination by outsider
humanitarians and agencies.
Second is the provision of greater specificity in ethical
guidance regarding appropriate behavior in international
emergencies. The development of the IASC Guidelines is
an important benchmark in this regard because they offer
extensive guidance by the most seasoned practitioners on
things to do and practices to avoid. In addition, the APA
(2008) has issued more specific guidance relevant to work
in international emergencies. Also, the APA Ethics Office
and the APA Office of International Affairs initiated in
2006 a multinational dialogue on the ethics of international
humanitarian response. This much-needed dialogue should
be continued and used by the APA Ethics Committee on
an ongoing basis to strengthen the APA Code of Ethics.
Third is improved documentation regarding the efficacy
of psychosocial interventions in emergency contexts. Too
few systematic evaluations are conducted, and outcomes
research remains underdeveloped in this still young field.
The conduct of contextually appropriate research on which
interventions are effective will help to establish an empiri-
cal foundation on which guidance can be constructed. A
particular need is for the documentation of do no harm
violations and means of managing them, as we as psycho-
social workers stand to learn at least as much from our
mistakes as from our successes. Too often, humanitarians
and agencies have been reluctant to document the unin-
tended negative consequences of their interventions be-
cause of concerns over image loss, reputational damage,
and possible loss of funding. These concerns, however, are
trumped by the humanitarian obligations for transparency
and protection of the rights of emergency-affected people.
In my experience, humanitarian workers can be convinced
to keep records of incidents of unintended harm if the doc-
umentation is done in a spirit of mutual learning and iden-
tifies ways of improving psychosocial practices without
pointing fingers and naming and shaming particular agen-
cies or people.
Fourth are improvements in the preparation of psycho-
social workers in international emergencies. Badly needed
are specific training on applied work in international emer-
gencies, including both natural disasters and armed con-
flicts; mentored or supervised field experiences in which
people learn by doing and reflecting in emergency con-
texts; the development of cultural and ethical competencies
pertaining to emergency situations; better understanding of
the humanitarian system; ongoing mentoring by seasoned
practitioners; holistic frameworks that interconnect psycho-
social work with work on wider social, political, and eco-
nomic reconstruction and long-term development; mastery
of elicitive, ethnographic methodologies that promote cul-
tural learning; and analysis of the sociohistoric, cultural,
and political dimensions of emergency contexts. Ulti-
mately, the system for preparing the next generation of
international psychosocial workers needs to be transformed
to enable ethical practice in international emergencies.
Collectively, these steps amount to a systematic trans-
formation in the approach that psychologists take to their
work in international emergencies. Although this transfor-
mation will take time, it is vital to begin the process soon
to provide the highest quality of support to emergency-
affected people at a moment in human history when the
frequency of disasters is expected to increase. I am confi-
dent that this journey of transformation will enable psy-
chology to make its fullest contribution to meeting the ur-
gent human needs spawned by emergencies.
Author’s Note
Michael G. Wessells, Mailman School of Public Health,
Columbia University, and Psychology Department, Ran-
dolph-Macon College.
Correspondence concerning this article should be ad-
dressed to Michael G. Wessells, 17028 Little River Drive,
Beaverdam, VA 23015-1767. E-mail: mwessell@rmc.edu
851November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
References
American Psychological Association. (2002). Ethical prin-
ciples of psychologists and code of conduct. Retrieved Sep-
tember 11, 2009, from http://www.apa.org/ethics/
code2002
American Psychological Association. (2008). APA state-
ment on the role of psychologists in international emergen-
cies [Statement]. Washington, DC: Author.
Anderson, M. (1999). Do no harm. Boulder, CO: Rienner.
Barbanel, L., & Sternberg, R. (Eds.). (2006). Psychological
interventions in times of crisis. New York: Springer.
Barber, B. K. (2001). Political violence, social integration,
and youth functioning: Palestinian youth from the Intifada.
Journal of Community Psychology, 29, 259–280.
Barber, B. K. (Ed.). (2009). Adolescents and war: How
youth deal with political violence. New York: Oxford Uni-
versity Press.
Batniji, R., Van Ommeren, M., & Saraceno, B. (2006).
Mental and social health in disasters: Relating qualitative
and social science research and the Sphere standard. Social
Science and Medicine, 62, 1853–1864.
Beristain, C. (1999). Humanitarian aid work: A critical
approach. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania.
Betancourt, T., Borisova, I., Rubin-Smith, J., Gingerich, J.,
Williams, T., & Agnew-Blais, J. (2008). Psychosocial ad-
justment and social reintegration of children associated
with armed forces and armed groups. Austin, TX: Psychol-
ogy Beyond Borders.
Betancourt, T. S., & Williams, T. (2008). Building an evi-
dence base on mental health interventions for children af-
fected by armed conflict. Intervention, 6, 39–56.
Bolton, P., Bass, J., Betancourt, T., Speelman, L., On-
yango, G., Clougherty, K., et al. (2007). Interventions for
depression symptoms among adolescent survivors of war
and displacement in northern Uganda: A randomized con-
trol trial. JAMA, 298, 519–527.
Bonano, G. (2004). Have we underestimated the human
capacity to thrive after extremely aversive events? Ameri-
can Psychologist, 59, 20–28.
Boothby, N., Crawford, J., & Halperin, J. (2006). Mozam-
bican child soldier life outcome study: Lessons learned in
rehabilitation and reintegration efforts. Global Public
Health 1, 87–107.
Boothby, N., Strang, A., & Wessells M. (Eds.). (2006). A
world turned upside down: Social ecological approaches to
children in war zones. Westport, CT: Kumarian.
Boyden, J., & Mann, G. (2005). Children’s risk, resilience,
and coping in extreme situations. In M. Ungar (Ed.), Hand-
book for working with children and youth: Pathways to
resilience across cultures and contexts (pp. 3–25). Thou-
sand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human develop-
ment. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Cardozo, B., Talley, L., Burton, A., & Crawford, C.
(2004). Karreni refugees living in Thai–Burma border
camps: Traumatic experiences, mental health outcomes,
and social functioning. Social Science & Medicine, 58,
2637–2644.
Carll, E. (Ed.). (2007). Trauma psychology (Vols. 1–2).
Westport, CT: Praeger.
Dawes, A., & Cairns, E. (1998). The Machel Study: Di-
lemmas of cultural sensitivity and universal rights of chil-
dren. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psychology, 4,
335–348.
de Jong, J. (Ed.). (2002). Trauma, war, and violence: Pub-
lic mental health in socio-cultural context. New York: Klu-
wer Academic.
Ehrenreich, J. (2006). Managing stress in humanitarian aid
workers: The role of the humanitarian aid organization. In
G. Reyes & G. Jacobs (Eds.), Handbook of international
disaster psychology (Vol. 4, pp. 99–112). Westport, CT:
Praeger.
Everly, G. S., Jr., & Mitchell, J. (1999). Critical incident
stress management (CISM): A new era and standard of
care in crisis intervention (2nd ed.). Ellicott City, MD:
Chevron.
Fisher, C., Hoagwood, K., Boyce, C., Duster, T., Frank,
D. A., Grisso, T., et al. (2002). Research ethics for mental
health science involving ethnic minority children and
youths. American Psychologist, 57, 1024–1040.
Galappatti, A. (2003). What is a psychosocial intervention?
Mapping the field in Sri Lanka. Intervention, 1(2), 3–17.
852 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
Green, B. L., Friedman, M. J., de Jong, J. T. V. M., So-
lomon, S. D., Keane, T. M., Fairbank, J. A., et al. (Eds.).
(2003). Trauma interventions in war and peace: Preven-
tion, practice, and policy. New York: Kluwer.
Hart, J., & Tyrer, B. (2006). Research with children living
in situations of armed conflict: Concepts, ethics & methods
(Refugee Studies Centre Working Paper No. 30). Oxford,
England: Queen Elizabeth House.
Hepburn, A. (2006). Running scared: When children be-
come separated in emergencies. In N. Boothby, A. Strang,
& M. Wessells (Eds.), A world turned upside down: Social
ecological approaches to children in war zones (pp. 63–
88). Bloomfield, CT: Kumarian.
Hobfoll, S. E., Watson, P., Bell, C. C., Brymer, M. J.,
Friedman, M., de Jong, J. T. V. M., et al. (2007). Five es-
sential elements of immediate and mid-term mass trauma
intervention: Empirical evidence. Psychiatry: Interpersonal
and Biological Processes, 70, 283–315.
Inter-Agency Standing Committee. (2002). Growing the
sheltering tree: Protecting rights through humanitarian
action. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
Inter-Agency Standing Committee. (2007). IASC guidelines
on mental health and psychosocial support in emergency
settings. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
Jacobs, G. A. (2007). The development and maturation of
humanitarian psychology. American Psychologist, 62, 932–
941.
Lee, J., & Sue, S. (2001). Clinical psychology and culture.
In D. Matsumoto (Ed.), The handbook of culture and psy-
chology (pp. 287–305). New York: Oxford University
Press.
Mackenzie, C., McDowell, C., & Pittaway, E. (2007). Be-
yond ‘do no harm’: The challenge of constructing ethical
relationships in refugee research. Journal of Refugee Stud-
ies. Advance online publication. doi:10.1093/jrs/fem008
Marsella, A., Bornemann, T., Ekblad, S., & Orley, J.
(Eds.). (1994). Amidst peril and pain. Washington, DC:
American Psychological Association.
Masten, A. (2001). Ordinary magic: Resilience processes in
development. American Psychologist, 56, 227–238.
Masten, A., & Obradović, J. (2007). Disaster preparation
and recovery: Lessons from research on resilience in hu-
man development. Ecology and Society, 13(1), art. 9. Re-
trieved from http:www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol13/iss1/
art9/
McKay, S., & Mazurana, D. (2004). Where are the girls?
Montreal, Quebec, Canada: International Centre for Human
Rights and Democratic Development.
Miller, K., & Fernando, G. (2008). Epidemiological assess-
ment in emergency settings: Recommendations for enhanc-
ing a potentially useful tool. Intervention, 6, 255–260.
Miller, K., & Rasco, L. (2004). The mental health of refu-
gees. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Minear, L. (2002). The humanitarian enterprise. Bloom-
field, CT: Kumarian.
Mollica, R., Pole, C., Son, L., Murray, C., & Tor, S.
(1997). Effects of war trauma on Cambodian refugee ado-
lescents’ functional health and mental health status. Jour-
nal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psy-
chiatry, 36, 1098–1106.
Mukherjee, P., & Alpert, J. (2006). Overview of psycho-
logical intervention in the acute aftermath of disaster. In L.
Barbanel & R. Sternberg (Eds.), Psychological interven-
tions in times of crisis (pp. 3–35). New York: Springer.
Prendergast, J. (1996). Frontline diplomacy: Humanitarian
aid and conflict in Africa. Boulder, CO: Rienner.
Prewitt Diaz, J. O. (2008). Integrating psychosocial pro-
grams in multisector responses to international disasters.
American Psychologist, 63, 820–827.
Punamaki, R. (1989). Political violence and mental health.
International Journal of Mental Health, 17, 3–15.
Reyes, G., & Jacobs, G. (Eds.). (2006). Handbook of inter-
national disaster psychology (Vols. 1–4). Westport, CT:
Praeger.
Rutter, M. (1979). Protective factors in children’s response
to stress and disadvantage. In M. Kint & J. Rolf (Eds.),
Primary prevention of psychopathology: Vol. 3. Social
competence in children (pp. 49–74). Hanover, NH: Univer-
sity Press of New England.
Rutter, M. (1985). Resilience in the face of adversity. Brit-
ish Journal of Psychiatry, 147, 598–611.
Summerfield, D. (2001). Discussion Guide 1: The nature of
conflict and the implications for appropriate psychosocial
responses. In M. Loughry & A. Ager (Eds.), The refugee
853November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
experience: Psychosocial training module (Rev. ed., pp.
28–56). Oxford, England: Refugee Studies Centre.
Thabet, A. A., Vostanis, P., & Karim, K. (2005). Group
crisis intervention for children during ongoing war conflict.
European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 14, 262–269.
UNICEF. (2007). The Paris Principles: Principles and
guidelines on children associated with armed forces or
armed groups. New York: Author.
van der Kolk, B. A., MacFarlane, A. C., & Weisaeth, L.
(Eds.). (1996). Traumatic stress: The effects of overwhelm-
ing experience on mind, body, and society. New York:
Guilford Press.
Wessells, M. G. (1999). Culture, power, and community:
Intercultural approaches to psychosocial assistance and
healing. In K. Nader, N. Dubrow, & B. Stamm (Eds.),
Honoring differences: Cultural issues in the treatment of
trauma and loss (pp. 267–282). New York: Taylor & Fran-
cis.
Wessells, M. G. (2006). Child soldiers: From violence to
protection. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Wessells, M. G. (2007). Post-conflict healing and recon-
struction for peace: The power of social mobilization. In
J. D. White & A. J. Marsella (Eds.), Fear of persecution:
Global human rights, international law, and human well-
being (pp. 257–278). New York: Lexington.
Wessells, M. G. (2008). Do no harm: Challenges in orga-
nizing psychosocial support to displaced people in emer-
gency settings. Refuge, 25(1), 6–14.
Wessells, M. G. (2009). Community reconciliation and
post-conflict reconstruction for peace. In J. de Rivera (Ed.),
Handbook on building a culture of peace (pp. 349–361).
New York: Springer.
Wessells, M. G. (in press). What are we learning about
community-based child protection mechanisms? An inter-
agency review of evidence from humanitarian and develop-
ment settings. London: Save the Children UK.
Wessells, M. G., & Monteiro, C. (2001). Psychosocial in-
terventions and post-war reconstruction in Angola: Inter-
weaving Western and traditional approaches. In D.
Christie, R. V. Wagner, & D. Winter (Eds.), Peace, con-
flict, and violence: Peace psychology for the 21st century
(pp. 262–275). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Wessells, M. G., & Monteiro, C. (2004). Healing the
wounds following protracted conflict in Angola: A commu-
nity-based approach to assisting war-affected children. In
U. P. Gielen, J. Fish, & J. G. Draguns (Eds.), Handbook of
culture, therapy, and healing (pp. 321–341). Mahwah, NJ:
Erlbaum.
Wessells, M. G., & van Ommeren, M. (2008). Developing
inter-agency guidelines on mental health and psychological
support in emergency settings. Intervention, 6, 199–218.
Wilson, J., & Drozdek, B. (2004). Broken spirits: The
treatment of traumatized asylum seekers, refugees, war and
torture victims. New York: Brunner-Routledge.
854 November 2009 ● American Psychologist
Th
is
d
oc
um
en
t i
s c
op
yr
ig
ht
ed
b
y
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
P
sy
ch
ol
og
ic
al
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
o
ne
o
f i
ts
a
lli
ed
p
ub
lis
he
rs
.
Th
is
a
rti
cl
e
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r t
he
p
er
so
na
l u
se
o
f t
he
in
di
vi
du
al
u
se
r a
nd
is
n
ot
to
b
e
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
b
ro
ad
ly
.
International Humanitarian Award
Citation
“Using his knowledge of qualitative and ethnographic
methods, Sunil Bhatia has formed alliances with over a
dozen community partners and nongovernmental organiza-
tions (NGOs) in the United States and in his native city of
Pune, India, to provide the urban poor with access to clean
sanitation and private toilets. He has brought a taboo
subject—open defecation—into the spotlight to show how
lack of sanitation is connected to psychological constructs
of privacy, dignity, humiliation, and safety. His communi-
ty-based approach with Shelter Associates, a local NGO,
has created a sustainable program of sanitation that has
improved physical and psychological health for those living
in the vast slums of Pune, Sangli, and Miraj, India.”
Sunil Bhatia is Professor and Past-Chair of Human Devel-
opment at Connecticut College. Sunil received his doctoral
degree in developmental psychology from Clark University
in 1998 and joined Connecticut College in 1999. Bhatia
grew up in Pune, India, in a residential neighborhood called
Pudumjee Compound in Bhawani Peth. He received his
bachelor’s degree in psychology from Nowrosjee Wadia
College and his master’s degree in psychology from Uni-
versity of Pune.
Bhatia’s scholarship specifically examines how theoret-
ical concepts such as culture, power, and representation
shape theories of acculturation, racial, and cultural identity
in human development and cultural psychology. His re-
search focuses on the development of self and identity
within the context of postcolonial conditions of migration,
globalization, neoliberalization, and the formation of trans-
national diasporas. Bhatia’s scholarship emerges out of
intersections between critical psychology and ethnographic
and qualitative methods to address questions of marginal-
ization and social justice.
His publications include the book American Karma:
Race, Culture and Identity in the Indian Diaspora (2007,
New York University Press). The book advances the field
of psychology by incorporating critical issues related to the
concept of culture, including race, diaspora identity of
Indian immigrants, and transnational migration. American
Karma, which has garnered extremely positive reviews in
top peer-reviewed journals, also provides key insights for
the fields of psychology, anthropology, sociology, human
development, and Asian American studies. Sunil has pub-
lished over 30 articles and book chapters on issues related
to transnational migration, identity, and cultural psychol-
ogy. His articles have appeared in top-tiered journals, in-
cluding American Psychologist, Human Development, The-
ory and Psychology, History of Psychology, Culture and
Psychology, Journal of Intercultural Studies, and Journal
of Theoretical and Philosophical Psycholog
y.
Bhatia was recently appointed as one of the associate
editors of Journal of Theoretical and Philosophical Psy-
chology, and he also serves on the editorial board of the
journals Qualitative Psychology and History of Psychology.
He currently serves as the Program Chair for Division 24 of
the American Psychological Association’s convention in
2015 in Toronto. In 2014, the American Psychological
Association elected Sunil as a “Fellow” of Division 24 for
his outstanding local, national, and international contribu-
tions to the field of psychology.
In 2006, Professor Bhatia received the 2006 Sigmund
Koch Award for Early Career Contribution to Psychology,
which is presented by Division 24 to a psychologist each
year who is within 10 years of having earned a doctorate
degree and has made promising contributions to theoretical
or philosophical psychology. In September 2005, Sunil
received Connecticut College’s prestigious John King
Teaching Award. In 2011, Campus Compact, a national
organization selected Sunil as one of the runners-up for the
nationally known Thomas Ehrlich Civically Engaged Fac-
ulty Award. This award is bestowed annually to recognize
faculty for exemplary leadership in advancing students’
civic learning, community engagement, and contributions
to the public good. In 2009, he received the Martin Luther
King Jr. Faculty Service Award, given to a faculty who
upholds the legacy of Dr. King’s work with their demon-
strated commitment to social justice and serving underrep-
resented communities. In 2007, he also received a Commu-
T
hi
s
do
cu
m
en
t
is
co
py
ri
gh
te
d
by
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
Ps
yc
ho
lo
gi
ca
l
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
on
e
of
its
al
lie
d
pu
bl
is
he
rs
.
T
hi
s
ar
tic
le
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r
th
e
pe
rs
on
al
us
e
of
th
e
in
di
vi
du
al
us
er
an
d
is
no
t
to
be
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
br
oa
dl
y.
816 November 2015 ● American Psychologist
© 2015 American Psychological Association 0003-066X/15/$12.00
Vol. 70, No. 8, 816–818 http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0039857
http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/a0039857
nity Service Award that is given by the Connecticut
Department of Higher Education. In 2001, the students of
Unity House at Connecticut College awarded Bhatia the
Tyrone Ferdnance Award for excellence in teaching and
community service.
Sunil Bhatia served as the director of the Holleran Center
for Public Policy and Community Action and from 2008 to
2011 at Connecticut College. Bhatia has studied the problem
of poverty within the Indian socioeconomic context and
draws his inspiration from the work of Pratima Joshi, the
Director of Shelter Associates. Approximately 60% of In-
dia’s 1.2 billion people defecate in the open, the world’s
worst sanitation record; 1,600 children under the age of 5 die
every day from maladies such as diarrhea, cholera, and ty-
phoid, caused by lack of proper sanitation; and 30% of
women from underprivileged areas experience violent sexual
assaults each year because the lack of sanitation facilities
makes them vulnerable.
Bhatia took specific actions to improve the conditions of
individuals who were living in poverty and were experienc-
ing the indignities of open defecation his native city of Pune.
In 2006, he started Friends of Shelter Associates (FSA), a
federally registered 501c nonprofit organization in Rhode
Island. FSA acts as a mediator between the community
partner, Shelter Associates, and the general public in the
northeast of America. Through FSA, Bhatia raises awareness
about global poverty and lack of sanitation in slums of Pune,
and specifically raises funds to support Shelter Associates in
their efforts to bring sanitation to the urban poor in the city of
Pune. Comprised of architects, social workers, GIS experts,
and community workers, Shelter Associates works with the
urban poor, particularly women in informal settlements
(slums), to facilitate and provide technical support to com-
munity-managed housing, slum rehabilitation, and sanitation
projects.
In 2010, the United Nations declared sanitation as a hu-
man right, and Bhatia has consistently framed the problems
of sanitation as a violation of human rights and dignity.
Bhatia’s work through FSA has impacted the lives of the
most vulnerable citizens in Pune in the following areas: (a)
Disease: construction of sanitation systems has prevented the
spread of infectious diseases; (b) Psychological: women’s
risk of sexual assault has decreased considerably, as they do
not have to defecate in open areas; being able to defecate in
a toilet at home gives families psychological peace, privacy,
and dignity; and (c) Community engagement: community
members are an integral part of the data collection, planning,
and implementation of sanitation projects, thus making them
feel psychologically empowered.
Bhatia’s work has particularly highlighted that the phrase
“open defecation” masks the fundamental psychological suf-
fering that underlies the experience of defecating near the
open in railway tracks, open gutters, or in the fields. His
efforts have touched many lives, and for some of the most
vulnerable members of the community in Pune and Sangli,
receiving a toilet has been a profoundly life-changing expe-
rience. Bhatia’s social justice work in the slums of Pune
allows him to give back and maintain his ties to his home-
town in India. His humanitarian approach to providing san-
itation in slums of Pune is based on a profound understanding
of the cultural contexts in which slums function in India.
Bhatia’s work is genuinely collaborative and thoughtful, and
he views the local community living in slums as equal part-
ners who have voice, agency, and power in their lives. Bhatia
has used his knowledge he has gained as a cultural psychol-
ogist to show how lack of sanitation is deeply connected to
psychological constructs of dignity, humiliation, and safety.
In his forthcoming book, Psychology of Globalization: Nar-
ratives of Indian Youth From Call Centers to Chai Stalls, he
employs a narrative framework to examine how neoliberal
globalization has exacerbated the social and economic ineq-
uities for those urban citizens who live in slum communities.
Bhatia’s work with FSA goes beyond international hu-
manitarian work and shows how communities in diverse
locations can produce long-term transnational alliances that
contribute to the psychological well-being and dignity of
individuals living in marginalized communities. His work has
had a profound effect on his students, several of whom have
become directly involved in this cause. Bhatia believes that
his work with Shelter Associates goes beyond a charity
approach, as it supports an organization that involves com-
munities that are participating in their own urban planning.
He works with a local NGO that recognizes that poverty is
not the only trait that defines the poor. The urban poor have
agency, voice, and the ability to advocate for themselves.
Bhatia has created awareness about the consequences of lack
sanitation by speaking at universities, churches, schools, and
local communities, and he has raised awareness about the
terrible sanitation conditions that exist around the world by
writing op-eds and commentaries. In addition, he has formed
several community partnerships in and around New England.
Over 1,000 people have participated in various FSA-related
events as guests, student performers, volunteers, and speak-
ers.
Bhatia, S. (2000). Language socialization and the construction of socio-
moral meanings. Journal of Moral Education, 29, 149–166.
Bhatia, S. (2001). Social acts, class, and the construction of personhood in
Indian families. Early Education and Development, 12, 433–454.
Bhatia, S. (2002a). Acculturation, dialogical voices, and the construction of
the diasporic self. Theory and Psychology, 12, 55–77.
Bhatia, S. (2002b). Orientalism in Euro-American and Indian psychology:
Historical representation of “natives” in colonial and postcolonial con-
texts. History of Psychology, 5, 376–398.
Bhatia, S. (2006). Reinterpreting the inner self in global India: “Malevolent
mothers,” “Distant fathers,” and the development of children’s identity.
Culture and Psychology, 12, 378–392.
Bhatia, S. (2007a). Opening up cultural psychology: Analyzing race, cul-
ture, and identity. Human Development, 50, 320–327.
T
hi
s
do
cu
m
en
t
is
co
py
ri
gh
te
d
by
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
Ps
yc
ho
lo
gi
ca
l
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
on
e
of
its
al
lie
d
pu
bl
is
he
rs
.
T
hi
s
ar
tic
le
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r
th
e
pe
rs
on
al
us
e
of
th
e
in
di
vi
du
al
us
er
an
d
is
no
t
to
be
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
br
oa
dl
y.
817November 2015 ● American Psychologist
Bhatia, S. (2007b). American karma: Race, culture, and identity in the
Indian diaspora. New York, NY: New York University Press.
Bhatia, S. (2008). Rethinking culture and identity in psychology: Towards
a transnational cultural Psychology. Journal of Theoretical and Philo-
sophical
Bhatia, S. (2010). Interpreting the meanings of schooling, hybridity, and
multicultural citizenship in diaspora communities. In W. Penuel & K.
O’Connor (Eds.), Learning Research in Human Science. National Study
for the Society of Education, 109, 66–81.
Bhatia, S. (2011a). Lost in translation: Cultural hybridity, acculturation, and
human development. Human Development, 54, 400–407.
Bhatia, S. (2011b). Narrative inquiry as cultural psychology: Meaning-
making in a contested global world. Narrative Inquiry, 21, 345–352.
Bhatia, S. (2012). Strategic subversions of the sacred: The cultural psychol-
ogy of religious identity. Commentary on Rosa Traversa’s, “Religion
made me free”: Cultural constructions of female religiosity. Culture and
Psychology, 18, 60–75.
Bhatia, S. (2013). Orientalism. In T. Teo (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Critical
Psychology (pp. 1294–1300). New York, NY: Springer Publishers. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-5583-7_20
Bhatia, S. (forthcoming). The psychology of globalization: Narratives of
Indian youth identity from call centers to chai stalls. New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
Bhatia, S., & Ram, A. (2001a). Locating the dialogical self in the age of
transnational migrations, border crossings and diasporas. Culture and
Psychology, 7, 297–309.
Bhatia, S., & Ram, A. (2001b). Rethinking “acculturation” in relation to
diasporic cultures and postcolonial identities. Human Development, 44,
1–17.
Bhatia, S., & Ram, A. (2004). Culture, hybridity and the dialogical self:
Cases from the South-Asian diaspora. Mind, Culture and Activity, 11,
224–240.
Bhatia, S., & Ram, A. (2009). Theorizing identity in transnational and
diaspora: A critical approach to acculturation. International Journal for
Intercultural Research, 33, 14–149.
Bhatia, S., & Stam, H. (2005). Critical engagements with culture and self.
Theory and Psychology, 15, 419–430.
Mascolo, F., & Bhatia, S. (2002). The dynamic construction of culture, self,
and social relations. Psychology and Developing Societies, 14, 56–89.
Shields, S., & Bhatia, S. (2009). Darwin on race, gender, and culture.
American Psychologist, 4, 111–119.
T
hi
s
do
cu
m
en
t
is
co
py
ri
gh
te
d
by
th
e
A
m
er
ic
an
Ps
yc
ho
lo
gi
ca
l
A
ss
oc
ia
tio
n
or
on
e
of
its
al
lie
d
pu
bl
is
he
rs
.
T
hi
s
ar
tic
le
is
in
te
nd
ed
so
le
ly
fo
r
th
e
pe
rs
on
al
us
e
of
th
e
in
di
vi
du
al
us
er
an
d
is
no
t
to
be
di
ss
em
in
at
ed
br
oa
dl
y.
818 November 2015 ● American Psychologist
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-5583-7_20
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-5583-7_20
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=fmcs20
Medicine, Conflict and Survival
ISSN: 1362-3699 (Print) 1743-9396 (Online) Journal homepage: https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/fmcs20
Psychosocial effects of the Chernobyl nuclear
disaster
Lynn Barnett
To cite this article: Lynn Barnett (2007) Psychosocial effects of the Chernobyl nuclear disaster ,
Medicine, Conflict and Survival, 23:1, 46-57, DOI: 10.1080/13623690601084591
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/13623690601084591
Published online: 29 Jan 2007.
Submit your article to this journal
Article views: 1042
View related articles
Citing articles: 7 View citing articles
https://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=fmcs20
https://www.tandfonline.com/loi/fmcs20
https://www.tandfonline.com/action/showCitFormats?doi=10.1080/13623690601084591
https://doi.org/10.1080/13623690601084591
https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?journalCode=fmcs20&show=instructions
https://www.tandfonline.com/action/authorSubmission?journalCode=fmcs20&show=instructions
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/mlt/10.1080/13623690601084591
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/mlt/10.1080/13623690601084591
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/citedby/10.1080/13623690601084591#tabModule
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/citedby/10.1080/13623690601084591#tabModule
Psychosocial effects of the Chernobyl nuclear
disaster*
LYNN BARNETT
Clannaborough, Nr Crediton, Devon
Abstract
The psychological factors surrounding the Chernobyl disaster include the sudden
trauma of evacuation, long-term effects of being a refugee, disruption of social
networks, illness, separation and its effects on families, children’s perception and
effects on their development and the threat of a long-term consequence with an
endless future. Added to this was the breakdown of the Soviet Union with
consequent collapse of health services, increasing poverty and malnutrition. These
complexities made necessary new individual and social treatment methods
developed in UNESCO Community Centres, within which some positives have
resulted, such as the development of individual and group self help and the
professions of counselling, social work and community development, practices
which did not previously exist in the Soviet Union.
Keywords: Chernobyl disaster, Child development, Psychosocial treatment,
Radiation, Refugees,
Trauma
The 26th of April 2006 was the twentieth anniversary of the explosion and
fire at the Chernobyl nuclear power station in Ukraine. The resulting
radioactive fallout has been estimated as equivalent to that of 200 of the
nuclear bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. It was the beginning
of a catastrophe that continues to affect millions of people in many parts of
Europe but particularly the three countries closest to the reactor, Ukraine,
Belarus and Russia. The affected populations have had to cope with
ongoing political, social, environmental and health consequences, together
with conflicting findings and recommendations of scientists and other
experts who disagree about the exact repercussions of the accident, as
evidenced by both official and unofficial reports.
*This paper is based on a talk given at a MEDACT conference at the Royal College of Surgeons, London,
on 22 April 2006.
Medicine, Conflict and Survival
January – March 2007; 23(1): 46 – 57
ISSN 1362-3699 print/ISSN 1743-9396 online � 2007 Taylor & Francis
DOI: 10.1080/13623690601084591
The author took part in a study tour of the Chernobyl complex and the
surrounding zones in 2004, organised by Friends of Chernobyl Centre, US
(FOCCUS); one of the main interests of the tour being visits to the
UNESCO Community Centres set up after the accident. The author and
some others in the group had taken part in the original social work and
counselling training courses for the staff of these centres, which were an
innovation in the Soviet Union at the time.
There have been many conflicting reports on the exact morbidity figures
following the Chernobyl disaster, but the issue is wider than that. A recent
edition of Nature quotes: ‘What we’d like people to take away is not the
numbers game (such as how many cancers or how many died) but a
recognition that Chernobyl’s most serious impact was on the mental health
of about seven million people labelled as victims of the accident’ [1]. In the
same edition of Nature, there is a call for ‘an international effort to monitor
all possible health consequences, using the studies of Japanese bomb
survivors as a model’, and:
in terms of public health, the psychological consequences of exposure to
the accident are probably more important than the physical conse-
quences . . . Millions were exposed to fallout; all must have some concern
for themselves and their children. For hundreds and thousands, fear of the
unknown was compounded by forced evacuation and loss of trust in
government, caused by poor risk communication . . . heightened by mis-
managed responses to the accident. At the time, the Soviet nuclear industry
and government failed to alert the public to take safety precautions [2].
Trauma
The severity of these stress factors mentioned above depends in part on the
proximity to the disaster and which of the four zones people lived in. The
population in the exclusion zone 1, which incorporates Pripyat, the nearest
city to the reactor, were the most seriously affected (135,000), but also
seriously affected were those living in the less contaminated zone 2, where
whole villages were pulled down and buried and 160,000 people from 170
settlements were evacuated. Those in zones 3 and 4 – 3.5 million people
including 1.2 million children – were not evacuated, but their land was still
contaminated and they have had to live in fear of the health consequences.
The following factors all need to be considered in context when assessing
mental health or psychosocial effects, which adds to the enormous difficulty
of assessment:
. knowledge of the accident and fear of the unknown consequences;
. forced and sudden evacuation with loss of personal possessions, home
and employment;
Psychosocial effects of Chernobyl 47
. disruption of stable social networks with evacuation to villages or towns
where new arrivals were often met with hostility and discrimination
from existing residents and in light of this there was often a struggle for
residency permits;
. unemployment;
. increasing poverty and ill-health; collapse of the health services because
of the breakdown of the Soviet Union;
. confusion about what food is safe to eat – what animals and plants –
sometimes leading to malnutrition;
. birth defects or their possibility;
. the promise of benefits which, even though minimal, often did not
materialise.
If we consider the nature of trauma, we can say that many of these
stressors alone can lead to symptoms of Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
(PTSD). In this disorder the breakdown of ‘normal’ social and economic
structures can contribute as much to the impact and subsequent distress as
the particular catastrophic events.
When a person experiences overwhelming stress, there occurs a natural
biphasic response which alternates between the avoidant phase (numbing,
withdrawal and denial) and the intrusive phase (recalling the event with
extreme affect, traumatic re-experiencing of the event and generalised
hyper-reactivity). These symptoms continue until the person can master the
experience.
Technological traumas are, however, experienced very differently from
other types of stressful situations. The inescapability, fear and extremely
horrifying sudden sensory overload may not be present. The traumatic
stressor could be no more than horrifying information, but this can be as
threatening although in a different way. Also delayed PTSD can occur
when the perception of the event changes, creating a re-definition and re-
experience of it as traumatogenic. This occurred with some of the
‘liquidators’, the soldiers, scientists and others sent to clear up after the
accident, who only later realised the danger to which they had been exposed
or into which they had sent others [3]. In addition, what is perceived and
experienced as horrifying, life-threatening and overwhelming by one person
may not be experienced in the same way by another.
We know from many follow-up studies that time alone does not always
heal. Studies carried out after the Second World War, the Gulf and
Yugoslavian Wars, show that children were still suffering PTSD years later
[4]; the Aberfan coal tip catastrophe where 29 per cent of the children still
had PTSD 33 years later [5]; the sinking of the Jupiter, where a seven-year
follow-up showed that 15 per cent of children still met the criteria for
PTSD [6]. Thus, people suffering from stress caused by trauma need help,
not necessarily psychiatric help, but the kinds of help that support natural
48 L. Barnett
healing processes and coping strategies. ‘In large scale disasters, stress
reactions are complicated by bereavement and depression. All the reactions
need to be properly assessed and treated, not only the few given recognition
by DSM’ (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of the American Psychiatric
Association) [6].
On the other hand the Chernobyl disaster was not only a technological
but a manmade catastrophe, and manmade catastrophes generally have a
more severe and more protracted psychological toll compared with natural
disasters [7]. Not only this but Chernobyl was a very different kind of
trauma, of cumulative stressors without a foreseeable end. A different
perspective on management and treatment of the traumas resulting from
technological and manmade disasters is needed.
A single stressor, such as a car accident, can lead to what is called ‘type 1’
trauma; multiple stressors such as occur in war are called ‘type 2’ trauma,
so perhaps trauma arising from disasters with no end in sight needs to be
recognised as ‘type 3’. Studies of the mental effects of cumulative trauma
suggest that repeated adversity may lead to symptoms and characterologic
distortions [8], and that there is a threshold for resistance to injury which, if
breached, will lead to a decline in functioning even in those who had
strength and resilience early in life.
A new branch of psychiatry has been proposed, Ecological Psychiatry,
being the study of mental disorders and mental health care after
environmental catastrophe [9], whilst others have suggested a category of
Sociostress Disorder, SSD, which does not fit into the current standard
psychiatric classifications [10]. It is suggested that SSD alters not just an
individual’s but a population’s functional abilities with variants including
psycho-physiological reactions, psychogenic adaptive reactions, neurotic
states, neurotic personality development and acute reactions to the
situation.
The debate about the evolution of posttraumatic morbidity has been
concerned about whether it is the objective severity of stressor or
premorbid vulnerability that predominates. But for a full understanding,
we must take account of the social, and societal, context in which
personal distress or disorder is being played out and with which it is
interacting’ [11].
Researchers in South Africa [12] and earlier in Auschwitz [13] found that
those who understood, in political terms, what had happened to them could
better survive. The secrecy and lies that enshrouded the Chernobyl
accident led to an almost total lack of knowledge about the facts, political or
otherwise, leading to the impossibility of any kind of personal control.
The unseen, unheard, unfelt and unsmelt terror was too difficult for
people to fight against or even, sometimes, to be afraid of. People made up
Psychosocial effects of Chernobyl 49
their own stories and myths about what had happened and how to deal with
it, studies showing that the myths divided into categories of optimistic/
pessimistic, active/passive and myths of chance (fate) [14]. An optimistic
myth was that small doses of radiation are useful for people of middle and
old age; a pessimistic myth was that only concrete can protect a person from
radiation and therefore all will die. Each myth is linked with either active or
passive behaviour, and the researchers see passivity and dependency as ‘one
of the most acute problems for communities and perhaps for society as a
whole’ [14: 174].
In these studies the material losses caused by the disaster were not
important components in a person’s psychological evaluation of the
situation; ways of coping often had a ‘magical’ element. It was found, for
example, that even 15 years later 90 per cent of the population was vague
about the nature of radiation, and some believed that drinking red wine or
swabbing throats with antiseptic iodine or using detergent rather than soap
was a protection against it.
Individuals under severe threat also process information differently.
Those who work with trauma victims report that their focus of attention
narrows to that which is causing the fear and a possible means of escape.
Later, if the fear state is re-triggered the mental states present at the time of
the trauma return. There is a tendency for those whose beliefs are based on
alarming experiences to retain and continue to collect information that
confirms their beliefs, discarding all else. In other words it is hard to change
attitudes. In the Chernobyl situation, escape was almost impossible, for
even after leaving the country the fear remains. Further, because of the early
lack of information and the lies and delays in receiving help, people became
very untrusting of later information even when it was true. This lack of trust
in information increases stress levels, as does the constant re-arousal of
emotions due to conflicting and/or constant information released over the
years, as new studies and research are published. Some manage this by
avoidance, others just despair.
For example at one point the UNESCO Centres, and some other
accessible places, were provided with Geiger counters so people could
measure the radioactivity of food they produced, bought or collected from
the forests. So much food was contaminated, however, that many gave up
measuring as they felt that otherwise they would not be able to feed their
families. It also interfered with traditional rituals such as gathering spring
mushrooms, which had been carried out for generations, so people went on
gathering them, despite the danger.
One woman (with thyroid problems) is reported as saying:
as the rules increased I began to see that it was impossible to do
everything they said. How could I keep the cat from coming in and out?
How could I live in a room where I never opened the windows? It was too
hard and I gave up and stopped listening . . . Now I don’t even react when
50 L. Barnett
I hear the news every spring about Chernobyl exploding again. There is
nothing I can do [3: 39].
Studies on stress and health
Studies over the past 20 years on the psychological effects of Chernobyl
have shown that depressive symptoms, anxiety, PTSD and unexplained
physical symptoms were two to four times higher in Chernobyl-exposed
populations compared with controls, although these symptoms rarely met
the level of criteria for a psychiatric disorder. Significant symptoms were
found up to 11 years after the accident, and the findings are consistent with
mental health patterns occurring after other toxic events, such as the atomic
bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the Three Mile Island accident and
Bhopal [15].
Ukrainian researchers have reported EEG changes, schizophrenia,
dementia, cognitive impairments and organic brain disorders in ‘liquida-
tors’, but alcoholism and other contributory factors were not always
evaluated. Many of the liquidators were army conscripts or inmates of
prisons, and many of those who lived were not followed up so the rates are
possibly much higher. It has also been suggested that ionising radiation
makes people hyper-sensitive to even the smallest environmental stressor
and accelerates the aging process [16].
It has been reported that the wives of the liquidators, and of other men
living in the contaminated areas, were afraid to sleep with their husbands in
case of having deformed children, so higher divorce or separation rates
became another consequence of the accident [17]. Many parents who had
to look after sick children either at home or in hospital also had marriage
difficulties as a result of the stress, one reason described as being the need
to ascribe blame. A further consequence is that many more children have
been admitted to orphanages either because of their illness, with which
parents can no longer cope, or because of poverty, including widowhood
caused by the accident, or fear [18].
A further factor causing severe stress in the Chernobyl situation is the
feeling of social alienation that can follow toxic contamination. A person
can view themselves as a freak or be so viewed, or even avoided, by others.
This occurred in Hiroshima and Nagasaki where irradiated people were
given the title of hibakusha. Contamination may also render their house,
land or workplace uninhabitable, not only shattering networks and
communities but also leading to a loss of role, sense of self and expectations
for the future.
The confusion, grief and inability of people to leave their contaminated
homes and possessions continues to be a terrible problem following
Chernobyl. People could not understand why they were forbidden to take
Psychosocial effects of Chernobyl 51
family treasures with them, or why the family cat, dog or livestock were to
be shot and buried. Some refused to leave their homes, running to hide
from the militias whose job it was to evacuate entire communities and
others returned illegally to live in contaminated areas. Many evacuees
were stunned to learn that after they left their entire villages were
bulldozed and buried beneath the soil [3: 37].
Children
Studies carried out in various European countries in the 1980s, during the
cold war when there was a danger of nuclear war, sheds some light on the
way children under ten years old react to nuclear issues, both power and
weapons, and particularly radiation [19]. Previous studies had shown that
adolescents were extremely worried about their futures. In the younger
age group it was found that the two issues, nuclear power and weapons,
were closely related in their minds. Talking about these matters raised
personal fears of death of parents and fears about their own aggression. It
was hard for the children to describe radiation because of its invisibility,
lack of smell, and feel. Some thought it was like acid rain, or acid, which
‘seeps through most substances, including metals’. They knew it polluted
the sea and fish and the air and birds. They said, ‘it contaminates, like
germs; it can get into your food, on your hands and so into your
body . . . it is like gas, invisible, but it can kill people by choking them or
poisoning them’.
The children, although anxious about things they heard on the news,
protected their parents by not telling them about their fears, and they would
‘change the subject’ if it came up. They coped by ‘trying not to think about
it’ (the boys in particular), or engaged in escape fantasies; one boy said he
would ‘go to the moon – there are no nuclear weapons there’, to which a
girl added, ‘Yes, and we could take bottles of gas’ [20].
Similar mental processes are likely to have occurred in the Chernobyl
young children, particularly as parents were highly stressed, which the
children would have picked up. In a UNESCO Community centre in the
first zone of radiation monitoring, the staff were worried that although
radiation levels had decreased, the anxiety of the children was getting
worse. A subsequent survey of children aged 12–14 years showed that
the children born after the accident had the most frightening
picture. Comments made included ‘Chernobyl is terrible, it affects the
fate of people’; ‘Chernobyl is what our parents are mostly worried about –
it affects the whole planet’; ‘ Chernobyl is my disease’; ‘Chernobyl is for
ever’.
Thyroid cancer is known to be a significant effect of the Chernobyl
accident, and one study reports a high level of psychiatric disorder in
children with cancer of the thyroid gland, with the rate of neurotic disorders
52 L. Barnett
twice as high in girls and of PTSD four times higher in girls [21]. One of the
compounding problems with ill children in the Ukraine is that they have to
be sent away from home for treatment as hospitals are so centralised. This
makes any medical interventions more traumatic, particularly if parents are
absent.
Several factors have been suggested which protect a child from the
detrimental effects of trauma, loss and change, but it can be seen from the
previous discussion that children in the Chernobyl situation are at extreme
risk.
. Being able to integrate the event into a meaning system (is there any
meaning to Chernobyl?).
. Gaining active mastery over traumatic events, either consciously or
unconsciously (this may involve the internalisation of bizarre experi-
ences and feelings and needs help).
. Being able to use natural healing processes such as play, dreams and
mourning to create a narrative, that is, something that makes sense.
(This is one of the major activities in the UNESCO centres’ trauma
work).
. Finding culturally syntonic forms of expression of loss and of
celebrating life, for example, recognising the gains of life after
evacuation. (Child evacuees had better housing sometimes, but suffered
the loss of school, friends and social networks. Again, this is something
worked on in the UNESCO Centres.)
. Having a parent (or substitute parent) who is able to contain one’s
anxiety. (Most commonly parents were themselves too anxious to
contain their own fears and anxieties let alone their children’s anxiety,
and parents became hypervigilant and over reactive.)
. Having access to one’s community and social network. (Those
displaced had neither. Those from highly contaminated areas such as
Pripyat will never again be able to return.)
We know from Attachment Theory [22] that events which threaten a
child’s sense of physical safety and the security of their tie to parents,
adversely affects their development. A longitudinal study of over 30
years duration [23] carried out in New York, on the relationship
between mothering in infancy and childhood trauma occurring after
infancy but before the age of 18 years, found that children experiencing
two or more adverse circumstances had significantly lower levels of
overall functioning as adults than those spared multiple traumas.
Further, those adults who had received more effective care in infancy
in terms of maternal empathy, consistency, control, thoughtfulness,
affection and management of aggression, had higher-level psychological
defence mechanisms than those who, as children, received less effective
parenting.
Psychosocial effects of Chernobyl 53
There are obvious implications for Chernobyl children whose mothers
were so preoccupied and whose empathy, as a consequence, was interfered
with.
Infants
‘For years officials were not allowed to label illnesses as Chernobyl
related so it is unclear yet whether or not birth defects are on the rise in
the region’ [3: 41]. Yet there are reports from studies of Chernobyl that
radionuclide induced psychoneurotic symptomatology takes place at all
periods of inter-uterine development, the period of late cerebrogenesis
(brain formation) being the most sensitive to radiation, leading to
disorders of speech and cognitive skills, lower IQ and emotional
disorders; and that infants who were in utero at the time of the accident
have cognitive impairments, depending on their stage of development
[24,25].
These findings are disputed by some researcher groups, including the
World Health Organization, and with some authors suggesting that in many
of the local studies, medical professionals did not have training in
psychosomatic medicine and therefore were unused to identifying and
managing psychological problems, neither were they trained in epidemiol-
ogy and social science research methods [15]. This makes interpreting
results of studies quite difficult and accounts for some of the disputes
between local and foreign studies. Whatever the truth, pregnancy and birth,
at the time of the accident until the present, is certainly a stressor for
parents who, even after an apparently normal delivery, still wait anxiously to
see what might develop in their children or grandchildren. As a Chernobyl
victim recalls:
Chernobyl will never be a joking matter for me. After the explosion, there
was a holiday. It was a very warm and sunny day. At that time we did not
know there was danger. My daughter was pregnant. She went to the beach
of the river in Kiev and sunbathed the entire day. This was probably the
worst exposure she could have had. For now her son is okay, but as we see
more and more cases of thyroid cancer in children from that time period,
we worry about her son and what his health will be [3: 15].
We know from much research that maternal stress has effects on the growth
of the foetus.
Information was received in small doses, sometimes with much delay
following the accident, and in fragmentary and contradictory ways. Because
information is applied personally, the acute phase of the disaster may occur
in a highly personal way much later, as the toxic contamination is revealed
in people’s own lives. For example a father’s concerns about his boy born in
Ukraine at the time of the accident: the family had moved to Russia and
54 L. Barnett
then America, but months later they noticed the boy had a lump on his
thyroid. ‘I thought we were through with these things. We live in America
now, it’s in our past, but here it comes to us again. I haven’t slept for weeks
I’ve been so sick with worry’ [3: 16].
Further difficulties arise from the way stress and anxiety can interfere
with relationships. This has already been discussed in terms of marital
relationships and children’s development, but it is also vital to understand
its impact on maternal–infant relationships, which are the building blocks of
healthy personality development, resilience and emotional security.
Trauma and unresolved grief have been described as blocking the
integration of left and right hemisphere activity, which is necessary to
experience complex dyadic states, the essential ‘attuned communication’
between an infant and its mother. Mothers experiencing trauma may thus
be less able to take part in the complex process of attachment essential for
healthy infant development.
Thus child development at all stages has been interfered with by the
traumas resulting from the Chernobyl disaster, but many who have assessed
the aftermath have not taken this into consideration. Much of the effects, of
course, are difficult to ‘measure’ but this does not mean it cannot be done
or that they are inconsequential.
Conclusion
Generalising about the psychosocial factors resulting from the Chernobyl
disaster is a difficult task because of the different types of risk involved:
liquidators from 1986 to 1990; evacuated people from Pripyat and the
30 km zone; settlers from evacuated areas, either forced or voluntary;
people still residing in contaminated areas and children of different ages
born from all these groups and at different periods of contamination. All
had different experiences and degrees of radiation exposure. It is also
difficult because different people react to trauma and stress in different
ways and because information is collected in different ways.
Some of the coping and non-coping mechanisms have been outlined:
defensive blocking out of problems or denial, repression, depression,
magical thinking, drugs, alcohol and suicide; generalised mistrust of the
government and officials; victimization and learned helplessness and
illnesses of many kinds, both physical and mental.
For some children even ordinary life events such as first going to
school, moving house or birth of a sibling, involve significant stress. They
are all factors which interrupt ‘the architecture of every day life’ [26].
Imagine then, the appalling and continuing stress the Chernobyl children
and their parents have suffered and are still suffering. Is it any wonder
that the degree of physical and mental illness caused by the psychosocial
stress factors discussed is high, quite apart from the medical effects of
radiation?
Psychosocial effects of Chernobyl 55
References
1. Vinton L. Quoted in: Peplow M. Counting the dead. Nature 2006; 440: 982–3.
2. Williams D, Baverstock K. Chernobyl and the future: too soon for a final diagnosis.
Nature 2006; 440: 993–4.
3. Speckhard AC. Mental health effects of technological disaster: the psychological aftermath
of toxic contamination. In: Berkovitz L, Patrick M, Berkovitz N, editors. Chernobyl: the
event
and the aftermath. Madison WI: Goblin Fern Press; 2001.
4. Dyregrov A, Gjestad R, Raundalen M. Children exposed to warfare: a longitudinal study.
J Trauma Stress 2002; 15(1): 59–68.
5. Morgan L, Scourfield J, Williams D, Jasper A, Lewis G. The Aberfan disaster: 33-year
follow-up of survivors. Br J Psychiatry 2003; 182: 532–6.
6. Yule W. Review of: Klingman A, Cohen E. School-based multisystemic interventions for
mass trauma. New York: Kluwer Academic; 2004. Child and Adolescent Mental Health
2006; 11: 123–4.
7. Noris FH, Friedman MJ, Watson PJ. 60,000 disaster victims speak; Part 1. Psychiatry
2002; 65: 207–39.
8. Van de Kok B, McFarlane H, Weisaeth L. Traumatic stress. New York: Guilford Press;
1996.
9. Napreyenko AK, Loganovsky KN. Current problems of ecological psychiatry. In: Long-
term health consequences of the Chernobyl disaster. WHO and Association of Chernobyl
Physicians, 2nd International Conference, Chernobyl. Kiev: International Forum; 1998;
p 317.
10. Alexandrovski YA. Sociostress disorders in Chernobyl NPP accident victims. In: Long-
term health consequences of the Chernobyl disaster. World Health Organization and
Association of Chernobyl Physicians, 2nd International Conference, Chernobyl. Kiev:
International Forum; 1998, p 435.
11. Summerfield D, Hume F. War and post-traumatic stress disorder: the question of social
context. J Nerv Ment Dis 1992; 181: 522.
12. Schwartz L, Levett A. Political repression and children in South Africa: construction of
damaging effects. Soc Sci Med 1989; 33: 670–80.
13. Bettleheim B. The informed heart. New York: Free Press; 1960.
14. Shvalb Y. Development and adaptation patterns among populations affected by the
Chernobyl disaster. In: Berkovitz L, Patrick M, Berkovitz N, editors. Chernobyl: the event
and the aftermath. Madison WI: Goblin Fern Press; 2001.
15. Bromet EJ, Havenaar JM. Psychological and perceived health effects of the Chernobyl
disaster: a 20 year review. Paper presented at meetings of NCRP & FOCCUS Arlington,
VA and Madison: April 2006. Available from FOCCUS, 5818 Anchorage Avenue,
Madison, WI, 53705, USA.
16. Akhaladze MG. Biological age assessment and Chernobyl disaster: cross sectional and
longitudinal studies. In: Long-term health consequences of the Chernobyl disaster. WHO
and Association of Chernobyl Physicians, 2nd International Conference, Chernobyl. Kiev:
International Forum; 1998, p 231.
17. Krysenko S. Psychological support in family disorders caused by Chernobyl catastrophe.
In: Long-term health consequences of the Chernobyl disaster. World Health Organization
and Association of Chernobyl Physicians, 2nd International Conference, Chernobyl. Kiev:
International Forum; 1998, p 467.
18. Walker L. Chernobyl children’s suffering. Guardian 1995 September 31.
19. Barnett LE, Lee I, editors. The nuclear mentality: a psychosocial analysis of the arms race.
London: Pluto; 1989.
20. Barnett LE. (Video) 1989 ‘‘Everything’s going berserk’’. Available from the
author or Concord video and film Council, Rosehill Centre, 22 Hines Rd, Ipswich,
IP39BG.
56 L. Barnett
21. Igumnov SA, Drozdovitch VV, Minenko VF. Mental and behavioural disorders among
children with thyroid cancer exposed following the Chernobyl accident: clinical and
dosimetry analysis. In: Long-term health consequences of the Chernobyl disaster. WHO
and Association of Chernobyl Physicians, 2nd International Conference, Chernobyl. Kiev:
International Forum; 1998, p 241.
22. Bowlby J. Attachment and loss, Vol 1, Attachment. NewYork: Basic Books; 1969.
23. Massie H, Szajnberg N. The relationship between mothering in infancy, childhood
experience and adult mental health: results of the Brody Prospective Longitudinal Study
from Birth to Age 30. Int. J. Psychoanal 2002; 83: 35–55.
24. Yermolina LA, et al. Mental health in children irradiated at different stages of inter-uterine
development as a result of Chernobyl disaster. In: Long-term health consequences of the
Chernobyl disaster. WHO and Association of Chernobyl Physicians, 2nd International
Conference, Chernobyl. Kiev: International Forum; 1998, p 231.
25. Nyagu AI, Loganovsky KN, Loganovska JA. Psychophysiologic after-effects of prenatal
irradiation. Int. J. Psychophysiol 1998; 30: 303–11.
26. Dunn J. Normative life events as risk factors in childhood. In: Rutter M, editor. Studies of
psychosocial risk: the power of longitudinal data. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press;
1988, p 227–34.
( Accepted 10 July 2006)
Lynn Barnett originally trained as a psychologist and social worker then later as an
anthropologist and child, adolescent and adult psychotherapist. She has consulted
to workers with traumatised children in Russia, Kazakstan, Former Yugoslavia,
China and UK. She recently retired from the NHS to devote more time to her video
series of cross cultural child development.
Correspondence: Lammacott Cottage, Clannaborough, Nr Crediton, Devon EX17
6DA; email: le.barnett@virgin.net.
Psychosocial effects of Chernobyl 57
CHAPTERTWENTY-SIX
HOW CAN LIVING WAGES SAVE OUR
GENERATION FOR A BETTER WORLD?
STUART CARR
MASSEY UNIVERSITY
Around the world, students are interested in and ready to engage with
the United Nations (UN) goals—on sustainable development out of poverty
and inequality (United Nations, 2018). This interest, which can readily be
found among students nationally and internationally, includes the
psychology of sustainability, in the context of teaching and learning. So, the
teaching of psychology has an interest in the sustainability issue. This
chapter is a potential discussion document for any such classes in the
teaching of psychology.
One of the most direct and sustainable pathways out of poverty is
finding a secure and decent job, one that pays an inclusive, living wage. In
2013, the International Labour Organization (ILO), World of Work Report
(ILO, 2013) concluded that reducing income inequality in the workplace is
a core, strategically important issue for the eradication of poverty to achieve
sustainable development for all. In particular, achieving shared prosperity
hinges on lowering excess CEO (Chief Executive Officer) pay ceilings
while, fundamentally, raising minimum wage floors to liveable but also
affordable levels.
This present paper focuses on that balance and how applied psychology
can contribute to this important agenda to eradicate poverty. As such, it is
intended as a teaching resource for instructors and students, in any courses
about work and livelihoods that touch on sustainability and poverty
eradication. The material has already been used extensively and
productively in this sense, as part of undergraduate and postgraduate courses
and seminars around the world, including for example in New Zealand,
South Africa, Colombia, Indonesia, and the United States.
How Can Living Wages Save Our Generation for a Better World?
401
The broader backdrop to the material is freely available by googling the
United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, or “SDGs.” These SDGs
represent Humanity’s most integrated, consulted, and arguably optimistic
plan for our collective development ever conceived (United Nations, 2018).
These are headed by SDG 1 (Eradicate poverty), including by Decent Work
(SDG 8), with economic inclusion (SDG 9), and through greater income
equality (SDG 10). However they also include, for instance, a global
education goal (SDG 4). The purpose of SDG 4 is to ensure inclusive and
equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for
all. SDG 4 also includes several sub-goals, which include for example
fostering skills for work (4.4) and sustainable development and global
citizenship (4.7).
Objective
In 2014, the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) report,
‘Barriers and Opportunities at the Base of the Pyramid’ (UNDP, 2014) found
that living wages are integral to enabling job quality, quality of life and work
life. Leading up to the SDGs, Oxfam (2014) reported that, even in the formal
sector, minimum wages globally have fallen short of real costs of living in
a range of countries, across global supply chains. In 2016, half of all people
classified in the world as “extremely poor” are not unemployed but working,
in jobs. Almost a billion of the world’s working population are earning just
$1.90-5.00 not per hour but per day. Redressing precarious, ‘working
poverty,’ by setting genuinely living—socially, psychologically and
economically—sustainable wages, has become a strategically crucial
objective for poverty eradication.
Purpose
While the idea of a living wage has captured public imagination,
creating a plethora of living wage campaigns globally, the actual social,
psychological and business benefits and risks of living wages have yet to be
fully articulated (GLOW/SIOP, 2016). Fair wage surveys have tended to
gather wage norms from populations with access to the Internet – thereby
excluding precisely the lowest income brackets whose quality of life, and
work life, are the most important and precarious. Living Wage campaigns
have tended to set living wage levels econometrically—for example using
cost-of-living surveys—without measuring any psychological, business or
broader societal benefits at all (Project GLOW, 2016). Astonishingly,
nobody has systematically gathered work- and household-level data on the
Chapter Twenty Seven
402
linkages at the very lowest ends, the nadirs of wage curves, between wages
and income on the one hand and everyday actual quality of life, work life,
and engagement/efficiency on the other. As a result, many employers remain
unconvinced that living wages are worth the risk. Project GLOW, which
includes Psychology educators, wants to break that deadlock.
Overview of the issue as it relates to our work
Psychology as a discipline and profession which is taught in Universities
and Schools and Colleges worldwide, has the infrastructure to address
further the concerns noted above. For example, the International
Association of Applied Psychology (IAAP) is the world’s foremost
international professional association of applied psychologists. Division 1
of the IAAP includes a strategic focus on promoting decent work
worldwide, through the application of rigorous and socially responsive
applied psychology in and from the workplace. The IAAP has participated
in multiple consultative rounds for the predecessors of the SDGs, the so-
called MDGs (Millennium Development Goals), as well as the SDGs
themselves. Additionally, the Institute for Multicultural Counseling &
Education Services, which is an international Non-Government
Organization (NGO) accredited at the UN (United Nations) promotes
human rights whilst cultivating health and resilience among individuals and
households. The Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology
(SIOP) is an association of the world’s top workplace behavioural scientists.
With more than 8,000 members from 43 countries, SIOP is a diverse group
with a key focus on improving the quality of working life on a global scale
and impacting on global organizations’ policies regarding corporate social
responsibility, gender/ethnic diversity and sustainability initiatives. Decent
work opportunities and living wages are central to these human service
goals.
Specific examples of Project GLOW’s accomplishments
and remaining challenges
Accomplishments
During 2016, psychology instructors, researchers and practitioners who
make up much of the GLOW network have successfully laid the human and
infrastructure foundations for Project GLOW (Global Living Organizational
Wage). GLOW comprises a unique global network of research service and
teaching hubs. Focused on everyday social and work life, it is an
How Can Living Wages Save Our Generation for a Better World?
403
interdisciplinary, cross-sector Partnership (SDG17) between work and
social sciences, practitioners, scholars and community groups, including
professional and labour associations. It has grown some capacity to answer
the following primary question: using Purchasing Power Parity (controlling
for inflation and other local impacts on what money can actually buy), “Is
there a Global Living Wage that enables people, organizations and
communities to prosper and thrive?” In GLOW, a living wage is defined as
a wage range in which both quality of life and organizational efficiency
undergo a significant upswing, but below which people’s inherent agency
(and jobs growth) languish in poverty traps.
GLOW now has at least one hub in more than 25 countries, spanning
trade routes and cities within and between them. It has an extended time-
span beyond the SDGs, of fifty years. This gives GLOW the capacity to
span multiple generations, and examine the temporal dynamics of living
wages on income mobility and shared prosperity. GLOW thereby has the
methodological capacity to systematically track changes in income mobility
and life opportunities in health and nutrition (SDGs 2 and 3), education
(SDG4), and gender equity (SDG5).
Capacity building
One key goal of GLOW is to grow the next generation of scholar
practitioners dedicated to poverty reduction. In keeping with its multi-
generational ethos, GLOW places a strong emphasis on building capacity
for future generations, for example by recruiting graduate students and by
enabling mobility of teachers, researchers and practitioners/consultants
between its hubs. GLOW has further recruited its own diplomatic corps,
whose social policy and business diplomacy skills and experience will
enable GLOW to follow the UN principles of ownership, alignment,
harmonization, accountability and evidence-based policy that were
emphasized as principles for enacting and achieving development goals in
the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness (2004). The vision for GLOW
thus includes adding value to wage negotiations along global supply chains,
for example, by marshalling evidence on what wages link to what qualities
of life, work life and work engagement.
Evidence-base(d)
GLOW members have published peer-reviewed conceptual,
methodological and empirical studies, for example with the ILO, from New
Zealand and South Africa. We have presented our models, methods and
Chapter Twenty Seven
404
findings across multiple international peer-reviewed conferences. Earlier
this year, for example, members presented the GLOW methodology for
gauging living wage levels, by invitation, at the recent UKAID/ESRC
(Economic and Social Research Council) “Impact Initiative for
International Development Research” Conference in Pretoria. Late in 2016,
and again in 2017, initially by invitation from the South African
government, GLOW presented South African findings about the (non-
linear, cusped) social and business efficiency linkages between wages and
quality of life, and work life, in a range of sectors from agriculture and
heavy industry to domestic work and business generation. This presentation
took place at South Africa’s major public science event, the second “Science
Forum South Africa”, in Pretoria on 8 and 9 December 2016.
Impacts
As we can see from the above, findings from the GLOW project are
informing wage policy setting at social, organizational, sector, national, and
international supply chain levels. Findings will show how these ranges and
inflexions are moderated by particular contextual influences, e.g., income
thresholds at which national debt industries allow, and peddle access to,
high-interest credit. Knowing the income range wherein quality of life, work
life and efficiency pivot sharply upwards and/or cross from negative to
positive quality of life, work life and engagement, is crucial for setting wage
levels to ensure sustainability of livelihoods globally and locally. Over the
mid- to longer-term, GLOW will potentially inform job creation, thereby
reducing unemployment.
Remaining challenges
Fragmentation/Harmonization. As long as wage policies remain
fragmented, even if living wage levels are determined and implemented,
jobs will continue to move to lower-wage economies. People from even
lower-waged economies will continue to move to where minimum wages
are higher for them by earning a less unliveable wage, to take economic
advantage of them – potentially fuelling any existing politics of xenophobia
and hate. Concerted harmonization of wage policies between countries and
within trade regions, i.e., truly “global” partnership including from
governments and multilateral bodies, is needed to break such depressive
circles.
How Can Living Wages Save Our Generation for a Better World?
405
Sustainable funding models
Some GLOW hubs have been supported by seed money from host
universities and professional associations, while other hubs are opting for
crowdfunding to become fully operational. More sustainable forms of
funding to support the teaching, researching, and advising on living wages
along supply chains and attached hubs will be required in order to
sustainably inform the points along a wage spectrum on which wages
become living, but GLOW expects to be positioned to apply to major
international funding bodies within 2-3 years.
A way forward: Specific recommendations
We call on the United Nations and the SDGs, through the Commission
for Social Development, which is a major UN Policy Forum, to endorse the
aims and ethos of Project GLOW, and to provide feedback and guidance on
how GLOW can continue to foster contributions towards sustainable
livelihoods and their role in poverty eradication. GLOW has potential facets
that cover every SDG. GLOW is therefore programmatic and fully
integrated with poverty eradication as a set of interlocking SDGs.
Closing
A major challenge for the SDGs, like the MDGs before them, is
operationalizing the macro-level SDGs at micro (individual, group) and
meso (for example organizational) levels. Poverty and inequality will not be
ended without research that shapes policy and community initiatives to
promote sustainable living wages. Living wages provide a mechanism for
operationalizing and advancing the SDGs in the context of people’s
everyday lives. GLOW is an instantiation of how to proceed in realising the
SDGs.
Acknowledgement
The preceding text is closely based on and in some places adapted from
a document that was submitted to the Commission for Social Development,
UN Economic and Social Council (December 2016), Fifty-fifth session 1-
10 February 2017: Follow-up to the World Summit for Social Development
and the twenty-fourth special session of the General Assembly. Priority
theme: Strategies for the eradication of poverty to achieve sustainable
development for all.
Chapter Twenty Seven
406
The Statement was prepared by EPIC (End Poverty & Inequality
Cluster, at Massey University, which is co-coordinated by Stuart Carr and
Darrin Hodgetts) and submitted by SIOP (Society for Industrial and
Organizational Psychology, through John H. Scott), a non-governmental
organization in consultative status with the Economic and Social Council of
the UN.
Statement citation and Acknowledgement: The Sustainable
Development Goals need to build a Social and Business Case for Living
Wages. E/CN.5/2017/NGO/7. New York: United Nations.
References
ILO (International Labour Organization). (2013). World of Work Report:
Repairing the Social and Economic Fabric. Geneva: ILO.
GLOW/SIOP. (Global Living Organisational Wage/Society for Industrial
and Organisational Psychology). (2016). The Sustainable Development
Goals need to build a Social and Business Case for Living Wages. New
York: UN Economic and Social Council, Commission for Social
Development, 1-10 February, NY, UN Report Number:
E/CN.5/2017/NGO/7.
Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness. (2004). Paris Declaration on Aid
Effectiveness. Paris: United Nations.
Project Glow. (2016). Glow Living Organisational Wage. 25 countries,
many more cities: Retrieved from http://www.massey.ac.nz/project-glow
UNDP (United Nations Development Programme). (2014). Barriers and
opportunities at the base of the pyramid. Istanbul: UNDP.
United Nations. (2018). The Sustainable Development Goals. New York:
United Nations.
https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/sustainable-development-
goals/ Accessed April 10, 2018, at 10.05 pm NZ time.
Students and Teachers: For more information on GLOW, including how to
join the project, please see the following video presented by John H.
Scott: https://youtu.be/zbZafHgqumo
http://www.massey.ac.nz/project-glow
https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/sustainable-development-goals/
https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/sustainable-development-goals/
Essay Writing Service Features
Our Experience
No matter how complex your assignment is, we can find the right professional for your specific task. Achiever Papers is an essay writing company that hires only the smartest minds to help you with your projects. Our expertise allows us to provide students with high-quality academic writing, editing & proofreading services.Free Features
Free revision policy
$10Free bibliography & reference
$8Free title page
$8Free formatting
$8How Our Dissertation Writing Service Works
First, you will need to complete an order form. It's not difficult but, if anything is unclear, you may always chat with us so that we can guide you through it. On the order form, you will need to include some basic information concerning your order: subject, topic, number of pages, etc. We also encourage our clients to upload any relevant information or sources that will help.
Complete the order form
Once we have all the information and instructions that we need, we select the most suitable writer for your assignment. While everything seems to be clear, the writer, who has complete knowledge of the subject, may need clarification from you. It is at that point that you would receive a call or email from us.
Writer’s assignment
As soon as the writer has finished, it will be delivered both to the website and to your email address so that you will not miss it. If your deadline is close at hand, we will place a call to you to make sure that you receive the paper on time.
Completing the order and download