Case Study

Content – Group based

Category

Failed

Partially

Mostly

Absolutely

Introduction (Case Overview, Key Issues and Problem Statement)

Failed to identify Introduction elements

Partially identified Introduction elements

Mostly identified Introduction elements

Absolutely identified Introduction elements

Analysis

Failed to provide relevant analysis or use any business analytical tool

Partial analysis with partially relevant business analytical tools.

Good analysis using two relevant business analytical tools.

Excellent analysis using two or more relevant business analytical tools.

Alternatives/

Recommendation

Failed to develop realistic Alternatives and failed to select a Recommendation to address key issues

Partially evaluated Alternatives. The selected Recommendation partially addresses key issues but is picked without decision matrix or risk analysis.

Good evaluation of Alternatives. Recommendation addresses most key issues and is picked using a decision matrix and most risks analysed.

Excellent evaluation of Alternatives. Recommendation addresses all key issues and is picked using a decision matrix and most risks analysed.

Answers to case questions

Failed to understand the question, hence answer/s are irrelevant

Partially answered the questions

Answers cover the main issues adequately

Excellent answers are given to cover the main concerns

Implementation Plan/ Conclusion

Failed to present a feasible Implementation plan and conclusion

Partially presented a feasible Implementation plan and conclusion

Mostly presented a feasible Implementation plan and conclusion

Absolutely presented a feasible Implementation plan and conclusion

Content – (identify one that is applicable)

Weight

0-24

25-32

33-39

40-50

Introduction (Overview, Problem Statement, Key Issues)

50

Analysis (Use at least two relevant business analytical tools )

Alternatives /Recommendation

Presentation

1

2

3

4

Communication

15

0-7

8-9

10-12

13-15

Professionalism

5

0-1.5

2-2.5

3-4

4.5-5

Power Point [Content & Design]

Question & Answer – part of presentation

Case Material

7

0-2

2-3

4-5

6-7

Timely Responses

6

3.5-4.5

5-6

Composure

Comments

Evaluator
Signature
_______________________________________________